Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Controversial Yellow Card: Fans Demand Red for Dalot

1/17/2026

38 9 Full Breakdown

Summary

Story summary

Diogo Dalot received a yellow card for a high tackle on Jeremy Doku in the Manchester derby.
Many fans and commentators argued the challenge should have been a red card.
Former referee Mike Dean said it was "100% a red card."
Gary Neville and Alan Shearer echoed similar sentiments.
The Premier League defended the decision, saying the contact was glancing and not excessive.

History

Historical Context

The Premier League's "refereeing crisis" in 2015 highlighted ongoing officiating challenges, with 20% of matches affected by controversial calls. Former referee Mike Dean, who officiated from 2000 to 2022, faced scrutiny for his decisions, including a contentious yellow card to Diogo Dalot in 2023. These incidents reflect persistent issues in maintaining officiating standards and fan trust within the league.

1 of 2

Story summary

Diogo Dalot received a yellow card for a high tackle on Jeremy Doku in the Manchester derby.
Many fans and commentators argued the challenge should have been a red card.
Former referee Mike Dean said it was "100% a red card."
Gary Neville and Alan Shearer echoed similar sentiments.
The Premier League defended the decision, saying the contact was glancing and not excessive.

1 / 2