Full Breakdown
Survivor Testifies on Negligence in Handling Sexual Assault Cases
1/19/2026, 4:25:34 AM
Testimony of Shaylee Atary
On October 7, 2023, Shaylee Atary, a survivor of a violent rape in 2011, testified before the Knesset Committee for the Advancement of the Status of Women and Gender Equality. Atary recounted her traumatic experience, stating, “In April 2011, I was violently raped on the asphalt of a residential parking lot beneath my apartment in Tel Aviv.” She emphasized the inadequacy of the state's response, claiming that the police were negligent and that the prosecution closed her case due to a lack of evidence. Atary criticized the court for protecting her alleged assailant with a gag order, which she argued obstructed justice and accountability.
Atary described the aftermath of the assault, detailing her physical injuries and the psychological trauma she endured, including a diagnosis of PTSD. She expressed frustration over the legal system, stating, “The justice system hands out gag orders to rapists like candy,” and highlighted the challenges faced by victims in pursuing justice. Atary's testimony was part of a broader discussion on the need for reforms in how sexual assault cases are handled in Israel.
Criticism of Law Enforcement and Legal System
During her testimony, Atary accused law enforcement of dismissiveness, noting that her main witness, who found her unconscious, was never questioned by the police. She stated, “Investigative materials showed negligence and a lack of will to find the truth.” Atary's case exemplifies systemic issues within the Israeli legal framework regarding sexual assault, where victims often feel marginalized and unsupported.
Another witness, Michal Gadisman, who previously worked as a senior secretary for former minister Silvan Shalom, also testified about her own experience of sexual assault. Gadisman urged lawmakers to prevent Shalom's appointment to a prominent position, asserting, “He should be behind bars.” She echoed Atary's concerns about the influence of powerful individuals in obstructing justice, claiming that her police file was closed for “lack of public interest.”
Legislative Proposals for Reform
In response to the testimonies, Atary and the Association of Rape Crisis Centers in Israel are drafting a bill aimed at reforming the legal process for sexual assault victims. This proposed legislation seeks to grant victims the right to be informed about proceedings related to gag orders and to express their opinions regarding such requests. Atary highlighted the need for victims to be recognized as parties in judicial proceedings, stating that current laws limit their rights and involvement.
Verbatim Quotes
- “The justice system hands out gag orders to rapists like candy,” — Shaylee Atary, Survivor
- “Investigative materials showed negligence and a lack of will to find the truth,” — Shaylee Atary, Survivor
- “He should be behind bars.” — Michal Gadisman, Former Secretary to Silvan Shalom
Conclusion
The testimonies presented at the Knesset underscore significant concerns regarding the treatment of sexual assault cases in Israel. Both Atary and Gadisman call for urgent reforms to ensure that victims receive the support and justice they deserve, highlighting the need for a legal system that prioritizes accountability and transparency.
