Full Breakdown
Ice Fishing Tragedy Claims Two Lives in Upstate New York
1/20/2026, 4:38:04 AM
Incident Overview
On January 19, 2026, a tragic incident occurred on Chaumont Pond in St. Lawrence County, New York, resulting in the deaths of two men during an ice fishing trip. The victims, identified as Bryan LaPlante, 33, from Newton Falls, and Michael Booth, 48, from Oswegatchie, fell through the ice while fishing. Remarkably, a 6-year-old boy, who was part of the group, survived the ordeal by walking home alone despite being drenched and freezing.
Sequence of Events
The fishing trip took a dire turn when the group’s snowmobile broke through the ice. According to state police, the older man, Booth, attempted to assist LaPlante, who was struggling in the water. However, Booth also fell through the ice while trying to help. Although he managed to climb out, he lost sight of LaPlante and Booth. Concerned for their safety, a relative, Patrick LaPlante, ventured out to search for them and discovered Bryan LaPlante in the icy water.
Emergency responders were alerted to the situation around 7:40 p.m. and arrived at the scene to find both men unresponsive in the water. They were subsequently transported to Gouverneur Hospital, where they were pronounced dead. Meanwhile, the young boy made his way home, where he was found by Patrick LaPlante, who had returned to warm up.
Survival and Rescue
The 6-year-old boy was taken to Clinton-Fine Hospital for treatment of hypothermia. His survival, walking home alone after the incident, has been described as miraculous given the circumstances. The police have not disclosed the exact relationship between the two men and the boy, but the incident has drawn significant attention due to the tragic loss of life and the boy's remarkable escape.
Official Statements & Responses
The St. Lawrence County Sheriff’s Department, which assisted in the rescue efforts, confirmed the details of the incident in a press release. They emphasized the dangers associated with ice fishing, particularly in conditions where the ice may not be stable.
Criticism & Opposition
While the incident has been met with sympathy for the families involved, some community members have raised concerns about the safety measures in place for ice fishing activities. There are calls for increased awareness regarding ice conditions and the risks associated with winter recreational activities.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
There are no significant conflicting reports regarding the incident itself; however, details about the relationship between the men and the boy remain unclear. Further information may emerge as investigations continue.
Verbatim Quotes
“Both were taken to Gouverneur Hospital, where they were pronounced dead.” — New York State Police
This tragic event serves as a stark reminder of the inherent dangers of ice fishing and the importance of safety precautions during winter activities.
