Yankees Explore Trade Options for Ryan McMahon

The New York Yankees are considering a trade involving third baseman Ryan McMahon, acquired from the Colorado Rockies on July 26, 2025. The primary motivation for this trade is to address the Yankees' inconsistent third base defense, which had seen six players rotate through the position during the season. McMahon provided a defensive upgrade, recording seven defensive runs saved in 54 games. However, his offensive performance was subpar, with a .641 OPS and a -3.4 offensive fWAR in 185 plate appearances. The Yankees owe McMahon $32 million over the next two seasons, prompting discussions about his trade value.

Newsweek

Analyst Jordan Leandre has proposed a trade that would send McMahon to the Los Angeles Angels while the Yankees would receive right-handed reliever Ryan Zeferjahn in return. Zeferjahn, who has a fastball averaging 97.5 mph, has struggled with his performance metrics but is viewed as a potential reclamation project for the Yankees. The proposal suggests that if the Yankees agree to cover $10 million of McMahon's contract, his remaining salary would become more manageable at an average annual value of $11 million.

Newsweek

Should the Yankees proceed with the trade, they would need to fill the void left at third base. Leandre recommends signing Yoan Moncada, a former Angels third baseman, who has had an injury-plagued career but could provide an offensive boost. Moncada's market value is estimated at $4.5 million for the upcoming season, making him a financially viable option compared to McMahon's contract.

Newsweek

While no official statements have been released by the Yankees regarding the potential trade, the analysis by Leandre highlights the strategic considerations behind moving McMahon. The Yankees are reportedly looking to bolster their bullpen while also addressing their offensive needs at third base.

Newsweek

Critics of the proposed trade may point to the risk of losing McMahon's defensive capabilities, which were a key factor in his acquisition. Additionally, Moncada's inconsistent performance raises questions about his ability to fulfill the Yankees' needs effectively.

Newsweek

As the offseason progresses, the Yankees will continue to evaluate their roster and potential trade opportunities. The outcome of negotiations regarding McMahon and the pursuit of Moncada will significantly impact the team's strategy heading into the 2026 season.

Newsweek

“McMahon doesn’t have a ton of value, especially with two years and $32 million remaining on his deal, Leandre wrote in an analysis for Just Baseball.” — Jordan Leandre, Analyst

Newsweek

“Zeferjahn averages 97.5 mph on his fastball and his sweeper is electric. His fastball also way underperformed expected data, with a .354 wOBA versus .299 expected.” — Jordan Leandre, Analyst

Newsweek

“He’s generally a good baseball player when he’s actually playing baseball,” — Jordan Leandre, Analyst

Newsweek