Full Breakdown
Exploring Marilyn Monroe: Two New Novels Offer Divergent Perspectives
1/20/2026, 8:43:20 PM
Overview of the Core Narrative
As the 100-year anniversary of Marilyn Monroe's birth approaches, two new novels, "The Last Days of Marilyn Monroe" by Imogen Edwards-Jones and James Patterson, and "When We Were Brilliant" by Lynn Cullen, provide contrasting portrayals of the iconic actress and the circumstances surrounding her tragic death.
Contrasting Narratives: "The Last Days of Marilyn Monroe"
"The Last Days of Marilyn Monroe" presents itself as a "true crime thriller," beginning with the dramatic discovery of Monroe's body by her housekeeper. However, the novel diverges from traditional thriller conventions, spending less than 100 pages on the final year of Monroe's life and only a fraction of that on the day of her death. Critics note that the book lacks a clear narrative focus, failing to present a protagonist or a compelling storyline that investigates the circumstances of her death. Instead, it offers a detailed account of Monroe's life, including her relationships and career, but ultimately does not deliver on its thriller promise.
A Different Lens: "When We Were Brilliant"
In contrast, "When We Were Brilliant" is narrated from the perspective of Eve Arnold, a renowned documentary photographer who captured Monroe's essence. This novel emphasizes female friendship and ambition, portraying Monroe as a complex individual rather than a mere subject of speculation. Cullen's narrative allows for a more intimate exploration of both women's lives, highlighting their shared struggles with motherhood and personal aspirations. The relationship between Arnold and Monroe is depicted as one of mutual support, providing a more empathetic view of Monroe's character.
Themes and Characterization
Both novels explore themes of motherhood and the challenges faced by women in their respective eras. In "When We Were Brilliant," Arnold and Monroe's experiences with miscarriage create a poignant bond, showcasing their vulnerabilities. Cullen's portrayal of Monroe is sympathetic, presenting her as a multifaceted individual rather than a tragic figure to be dissected. Conversely, "The Last Days of Marilyn Monroe" is criticized for its detached and almost clinical recounting of Monroe's life, lacking the emotional depth found in Cullen's work.
Official Statements & Responses
Critics have noted the stark differences in narrative style and thematic focus between the two novels. While "The Last Days of Marilyn Monroe" has been described as a missed opportunity to explore Monroe's death meaningfully, "When We Were Brilliant" has been praised for its heartfelt depiction of female relationships and the complexities of Monroe's life.
Verbatim Quotes
- “The cardinal sin of “The Last Days” is that it doesn’t choose a storyline.” — Reviewer, Los Angeles Times
- “It‘s also a loving portrayal of Eve Arnold’s life and career.” — Reviewer, Los Angeles Times
- “Through these shared battles, we get the picture that Arnold may have been the only person who witnessed Marilyn for who she really was.” — Reviewer, Los Angeles Times
Conclusion
As the literary landscape continues to evolve, these two novels reflect differing approaches to understanding Marilyn Monroe's legacy. While "The Last Days of Marilyn Monroe" attempts to blend biography with thriller elements, "When We Were Brilliant" offers a more nuanced and empathetic portrayal, celebrating the complexities of both Monroe and Arnold's lives.
