Full Breakdown
Nolan Arenado Declines Trade to Oakland Athletics
1/21/2026, 12:28:51 AM
Overview of the Trade Situation
Nolan Arenado, the eight-time All-Star third baseman, recently declined a trade that would have sent him from the St. Louis Cardinals to the Oakland Athletics. Instead, he opted to join the Arizona Diamondbacks, utilizing his no-trade clause to reject the Athletics' offer. The Athletics had reportedly agreed to take on a larger portion of Arenado's contract compared to the Diamondbacks, who will pay $11 million of the $42 million owed to Arenado over the next two seasons.
Reasons for Arenado's Decision
Arenado's preference for the Diamondbacks or the San Diego Padres over the Athletics is attributed to several factors. The Diamondbacks, having reached the World Series in 2023, offer a more competitive environment and play in a Major League stadium, unlike the Athletics, who will be playing in a temporary minor-league facility, Sutter Health Park, for the next two seasons. Additionally, Arizona's significantly lower state income tax may have influenced his decision.
Impact on the Oakland Athletics
The Athletics were in search of a veteran presence at third base to bolster their roster, which features a promising young core. With Arenado's rejection, the team is now evaluating its options for the position during spring training. Max Muncy, along with Brett Harris and Darell Hernaiz, are currently in contention for the starting role. The Athletics may also explore free-agent options, including Eugenio Suárez, who hit 49 home runs in 2025, or Miguel Andujar, who has previously played for the organization.
Official Statements & Responses
Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic reported that Arenado indicated he would not necessarily approve a trade to the Athletics, emphasizing his preference for other teams. The Athletics had hoped that acquiring Arenado would address their struggles at third base, where they had a collective batting average of .199 in 2025.
Criticism & Opposition
Critics argue that the Athletics' inability to secure a player of Arenado's caliber reflects broader issues within the organization, particularly their temporary home situation and lack of recent playoff appearances. The team has not reached the postseason since 2020, raising questions about their competitiveness in attracting top talent.
What's Next for the Athletics?
With Arenado off the table, the Athletics will continue to assess their third base options and may pursue trades or free-agent signings to strengthen their roster ahead of the 2026 season. The team has already made moves to acquire Jeff McNeil from the New York Mets, indicating a proactive approach to improving their infield.
Verbatim Quotes
- “would not necessarily approve a trade to the A’s.” — Ken Rosenthal, Sports Journalist
- “With Arenado out of the picture, the A’s currently intend to use Max Muncy at third base, with Brett Harris and Darell Hernaiz also in the mix,” — Ken Rosenthal, Sports Journalist
In summary, Nolan Arenado's decision to decline a trade to the Oakland Athletics in favor of the Arizona Diamondbacks highlights the complexities of player preferences and the challenges faced by teams in securing high-profile talent. The Athletics must now pivot to other options as they prepare for the upcoming season.
