Voter Sentiment on ICE and Immigration Policy Amid Controversy

A recent poll conducted by The New York Times and Siena University reveals significant voter sentiment regarding Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and President Donald Trump’s immigration policies. The survey, which included 1,625 registered voters from January 12 to 17, 2026, indicates that while half of the respondents support Trump’s deportation efforts, a substantial majority disapproves of ICE's operations.

The Hill

The poll shows that 63 percent of voters disapprove of how ICE is managing its responsibilities, with 55 percent expressing strong disapproval. Only 36 percent approve of ICE's actions. This discontent follows the fatal shooting of 37-year-old Renee Good by an ICE officer in Minneapolis, which sparked protests and unrest in the city. Local officials, including Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey, have criticized ICE's tactics, asserting that they have unfairly targeted both citizens and legal residents.

The Hill

In contrast to the disapproval of ICE, the poll indicates a divided opinion on deportation policies. Fifty percent of respondents support the Trump administration's deportation of undocumented immigrants, while 47 percent oppose it. This split reflects a broader ambivalence among voters regarding immigration issues, with 57 percent believing that Trump is focused on the wrong issues.

The Hill

The poll was conducted via telephone and text message, ensuring a diverse demographic representation. The margin of error is approximately 2.8 percentage points. The survey's timing, following the unrest in Minneapolis, likely influenced public sentiment regarding ICE's actions and the administration's immigration policies.

The Hill

Critics of ICE argue that the agency's aggressive tactics have exacerbated tensions in communities, with many believing that these operations make cities less safe. A separate CNN poll corroborates this sentiment, revealing that about half of respondents feel ICE's actions contribute to a decrease in safety. The ongoing protests against ICE operations highlight the growing discontent among citizens regarding federal immigration enforcement.

The Hill

Local officials and community leaders have called for a reevaluation of ICE's presence and tactics in their jurisdictions. Mayor Jacob Frey has been vocal in urging the Department of Homeland Security to withdraw its agents from Minneapolis, reflecting the local government's stance against federal immigration enforcement practices.

The Hill

• “focused on the wrong issues,” — Voter sentiment regarding Trump’s priorities

The Hill

The poll results underscore a complex landscape of public opinion on immigration enforcement under the Trump administration. While there is notable support for deportation policies, the overwhelming disapproval of ICE's methods suggests a significant disconnect between federal actions and community sentiments. As protests continue and local officials push back against ICE operations, the future of immigration policy remains a contentious issue in American politics.

The Hill