Full Breakdown
Violent Biker Brawl Leads to Major Felony Charges in Long Island
1/26/2026, 6:30:06 AM
Overview of the Incident
A violent confrontation between members of the Pagan’s Motorcycle Club and the Demons of Hell MC, a faction of the Hell’s Angels, erupted on Long Island, resulting in serious injuries and multiple felony charges. The incident occurred on September 14, 2026, when alleged members of the Demons of Hell disrupted a memorial service for a Pagan’s member at 1683 Sports Bar & Grille in West Islip. The altercation escalated into a chaotic melee that spilled onto Sunrise Highway, leading to significant violence involving weapons.
Details of the Brawl
The Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office reported that the brawl resulted in four individuals being stabbed and others suffering severe injuries from blunt force trauma. Notably, Christopher Clarke, 21, and Roger Clarke, 53, both associated with the Demons of Hell, allegedly stabbed a Pagan’s member and subsequently assaulted him with a hammer, necessitating emergency surgery. Another Pagan’s member was also stabbed, sustaining critical injuries to his liver and colon.
On the opposing side, Pagan’s members Joseph Bivona, 46, Michael Baffa, 57, and Robert Miller, 54, reportedly attacked a 76-year-old rival with baseball bats, causing severe head injuries that required multiple surgeries. The violence transitioned from the bar to a Phillips 66 gas station in Lindenhurst, where the situation intensified as approximately 15 bikers regrouped.
Legal Consequences
Following an extensive investigation lasting over five months, five members from both motorcycle clubs were indicted on gang-assault and other violent charges. Initially, the police categorized the incident as a civil disturbance, with only seven individuals charged with rioting. However, the DA's office has since expanded the scope of the case, leading to the recent indictments. The suspects were arraigned with bail amounts ranging from $250,000 to $750,000.
Official Statements & Responses
Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney condemned the violence, stating, “This was a brazen and dangerous outbreak of violence that put our community at risk.” He emphasized that such violent behavior would not be tolerated and reaffirmed the commitment to crack down on gang-related activities.
Criticism & Opposition
While the DA's office has taken a firm stance against gang violence, some community members have expressed concerns regarding the safety of public spaces where such incidents can occur. The initial classification of the event as a civil disturbance has also drawn scrutiny, suggesting a need for more proactive measures to prevent similar occurrences in the future.
Verbatim Quotes
- “This was a brazen and dangerous outbreak of violence that put our community at risk,” — Ray Tierney, Suffolk County District Attorney
- “Violence of this nature will not be tolerated,” — Ray Tierney, Suffolk County District Attorney
What's Next
The legal proceedings against the indicted members of the Pagan’s Motorcycle Club and the Demons of Hell MC are set to unfold in the coming months, with the DA's office indicating a continued focus on addressing gang violence in the region.
