Full Breakdown
Mississippi Court Reinstates Educator Fired for Reading Controversial Book
1/29/2026, 1:54:01 AM
Court Ruling Overturns Termination Decision
The Mississippi Court of Appeals has ruled in favor of Toby Price, a former assistant principal at Gary Road Elementary School, overturning the Hinds County School Board's decision to terminate his employment. Price was dismissed after reading the children's book "I Need a New Butt!" by Dawn McMillan to a second-grade class during Read Across America Day on March 1, 2022. The court found that the board's decision lacked substantial evidence and was arbitrary, stating that there was no proof of "unnecessary embarrassment" caused to the students.
Background of the Case
Price's reading of the book, which humorously discusses bodily functions, was initially met with administrative backlash. Following the reading, then-Hinds County District Superintendent Delescia Martin placed Price on administrative leave, leading to his termination two days later. The school board upheld the termination, claiming Price had acted unprofessionally. Price appealed this decision, arguing that the board failed to demonstrate that his actions violated professional standards and that he was denied due process.
Court's Findings
The Appeals Court criticized the school board's rationale, noting that similar books were available in the school library and had been read to students in the past without issue. The court emphasized that it was the board's responsibility to prove the book was inappropriate, not Price's duty to justify its appropriateness. The ruling highlighted that the board's decision appeared whimsical and lacked a solid foundation in the facts of the case.
Official Statements & Responses
In a statement following the ruling, Price expressed gratitude for the court's understanding, stating, "This ruling affirms that reading joyful, sometimes silly books to children is not misconduct—it’s education." PEN America, an organization advocating for free expression, also praised the decision, emphasizing the importance of protecting educators who foster a love of reading.
Criticism & Opposition
Despite the court's ruling, some critics argue that the decision reflects a broader issue of educational standards and appropriateness in children's literature. They contend that the book's content, which includes references to "butts," may not align with the expectations of all parents and educators regarding what is suitable for young children. However, the court's decision underscores the importance of literary freedom in educational settings.
What's Next
The case has been remanded back to the Hinds County Chancery Court for further proceedings, including determining the amount of back pay Price is owed. This ruling may set a precedent for similar cases involving educators and the materials they choose to present in classrooms, potentially influencing policies on educational content in Mississippi and beyond.
