Story perspectives

Keane and Neville: United Needs Experienced Manager, Not Carrick

1/29/2026

Summary

Story summary

Roy Keane, former Manchester United captain and pundit, argues Michael Carrick should not be appointed permanent manager because Carrick lacks the experience and knowledge to win titles.
Gary Neville, former Manchester United defender and pundit, supports Keane and says Carrick could benefit from serving as an assistant under a proven manager.
Both emphasize Manchester United needs a top-tier manager to handle pressures of leading one of the world's biggest clubs.

1 of 1

Story summary

Roy Keane, former Manchester United captain and pundit, argues Michael Carrick should not be appointed permanent manager because Carrick lacks the experience and knowledge to win titles.
Gary Neville, former Manchester United defender and pundit, supports Keane and says Carrick could benefit from serving as an assistant under a proven manager.
Both emphasize Manchester United needs a top-tier manager to handle pressures of leading one of the world's biggest clubs.