Story perspectives

BBC's Shetland Praised for Diverse Casting, Criticized for Bias

1/31/2026

38 7

Center

Diverse Casting Review

The review of BBC One's Shetland, by Anne Morrison and Chris Banatvala, highlights diverse casting.
It notes the Procurator Fiscal has been portrayed by actors of Tanzanian, Jamaican, and Indian heritage.
The report suggests this diversity may boost the show's popularity and appeal.
It finds that people of color are over-represented in senior law officer roles relative to Scotland's ethnic makeup and it criticizes the BBC for London-centric bias.

Right

Morrison Critiques Diversity

An independent review led by Anne Morrison and Chris Banatvala criticizes the BBC's 'tick box' diversity, saying it causes inauthentic portrayals and viewer dissatisfaction.
It highlights viewer complaints about recent casting choices, including Nathaniel Curtis in Doctor Who.
The review notes a London-centric culture that alienates audiences outside the capital.
It calls for better representation of working-class communities and for the BBC to improve authenticity and representation.

1 of 2

Diverse Casting Review

The review of BBC One's Shetland, by Anne Morrison and Chris Banatvala, highlights diverse casting.
It notes the Procurator Fiscal has been portrayed by actors of Tanzanian, Jamaican, and Indian heritage.
The report suggests this diversity may boost the show's popularity and appeal.
It finds that people of color are over-represented in senior law officer roles relative to Scotland's ethnic makeup and it criticizes the BBC for London-centric bias.

1 / 2