Full Breakdown
Bret Stephens Advocates for Reallocation of Resources in Fight Against Antisemitism
2/4/2026, 6:09:21 AM
Call to Dismantle the ADL
During the 46th annual State of World Jewry address at the 92nd Street Y in Manhattan, New York Times columnist Bret Stephens argued for the dismantling of the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) and a shift in focus from combating antisemitism to strengthening Jewish identity. He stated that the current efforts to combat antisemitism, which consume tens of millions of dollars annually, are "well-meaning but mostly wasted." Instead, Stephens urged that resources should be redirected toward building Jewish day schools, cultural institutions, and other initiatives that foster a robust Jewish identity.
Critique of Current Strategies
Stephens criticized the prevailing strategies of organizations like the ADL, which include education, monitoring, and advocacy against antisemitism. He contended that these approaches have not effectively reduced antisemitic beliefs or incidents, citing polling data indicating that one in five millennials and Gen Zs believe Jews caused the Holocaust. He emphasized that antisemitism is not fundamentally rooted in misinformation but rather in societal resentment towards Jewish distinctiveness and success.
Official Responses
ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt, who attended the address, responded to Stephens' critique by acknowledging the importance of investing in Jewish education and identity. However, he defended the ADL's role in combating antisemitism, highlighting its efforts in data collection on hate crimes and security training for Jewish institutions. Greenblatt stated, "You cannot have what Bret called a thriving Jewish people if they’re constantly under threat," emphasizing that a dual approach—both offense and defense—is necessary for a strong Jewish community.
Broader Implications
Stephens' remarks reflect a growing sentiment among some Jewish leaders that the community should focus inward rather than seeking validation or protection from broader coalitions. This perspective has gained traction in light of rising antisemitism, particularly following the October 7, 2023, Hamas-led attacks in Israel. Other speakers at the State of World Jewry address, such as Dan Senor and Bari Weiss, have echoed similar calls for Jewish renewal through investment in community institutions.
Criticism & Opposition
While Stephens' views resonate with some, they have also sparked debate within the Jewish community. Critics argue that dismantling established organizations like the ADL could undermine vital defenses against antisemitism. They contend that the ADL's work is crucial for ensuring safety and security for Jews, especially in an increasingly hostile environment.
Verbatim Quotes
- “The fight against antisemitism, which consumes tens of millions of dollars every year in Jewish philanthropy, is a well-meaning but mostly wasted effort,” — Bret Stephens, New York Times columnist
- “They do not hate us because of our faults and failures,” Stephens said.” — Bret Stephens
- “You cannot have what Bret called a thriving Jewish people if they’re constantly under threat.” — Jonathan Greenblatt, ADL CEO
Stephens' address has ignited a critical conversation about the future of Jewish identity and the effectiveness of current strategies against antisemitism, highlighting a pivotal moment for the American Jewish community.
