Controversy Surrounds Appointment of Phylisa Wisdom as NYC's Antisemitism Czar

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has appointed Phylisa Wisdom, the executive director of the progressive New York Jewish Agenda (NYJA), to lead the Mayor’s Office to Combat Antisemitism. This decision has sparked significant debate within the Jewish community, particularly among Orthodox and Hasidic leaders, due to Wisdom's previous work and her stance on various issues related to Israel and antisemitism.

Mamdani names new antisemitism czar — and she’s already facing ire of Orthodox Jewish communityMamdani picks progressive Jewish leader to head Office to Combat AntisemitismMamdani appoints head of progressive Jewish group to lead antisemitism officeZohran Mamdani names NY Jewish Agenda leader as antisemitism czarMayor Mamdani Announces New Executive Director of Mayor’s Office to Combat AntisemitismMamdani taps progressive Jewish leader to head Office to Combat Antisemitism, sparking controversyRepublican senator in Louisiana launches probe into Mamdani’s reversal of Israel executive orders

The Mayor's Office to Combat Antisemitism was established by former Mayor Eric Adams in May 2025 amid rising antisemitic incidents in the city. In January 2026, antisemitic hate crimes surged by 182% compared to the previous year, highlighting the urgency of effective leadership in this office. Mamdani, who has faced scrutiny for his pro-Palestinian positions, retained the office while repealing Adams' executive orders that defined antisemitism in ways that many Jewish leaders support.

Mamdani picks head of left-wing organization to lead NYC antisemitism officeMamdani appoints Phylisa Wisdom, progressive Jewish leader, to run Office to Combat AntisemitismMamdani appoints head of progressive Jewish group to lead antisemitism officeRepublican senator in Louisiana launches probe into Mamdani’s reversal of Israel executive ordersZohran Mamdani names NY Jewish Agenda leader as antisemitism czar

Wisdom has a background in advocacy and education, having previously worked for Yaffed, an organization that promotes oversight of secular education in Hasidic yeshivas. Her leadership at NYJA has been characterized by a commitment to liberal Zionism, opposing the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement while also criticizing Israeli policies, particularly during the Gaza conflict. Wisdom has expressed opposition to the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism, which has drawn criticism from various Jewish leaders.

Mamdani picks progressive Jewish leader to head Office to Combat Antisemitism

Wisdom's appointment has been met with skepticism from some Orthodox and Hasidic leaders who argue that her past criticisms of yeshivas could hinder her ability to build trust within communities that are frequently targeted by antisemitic attacks. Rabbi Marc Schneier, president of the Foundation for Ethnic Understanding, stated, “The leader of the Office to Combat Antisemitism must understand a basic truth. Israel cannot be bifurcated from Judaism.” Critics argue that Wisdom's opposition to the IHRA definition raises concerns about her commitment to combating antisemitism effectively.

Mamdani taps progressive Jewish leader to head Office to Combat Antisemitism, sparking controversyMamdani picks progressive Jewish leader to head Office to Combat AntisemitismZohran Mamdani names NY Jewish Agenda leader as antisemitism czarMamdani picks head of left-wing organization to lead NYC antisemitism officeMamdani appoints Phylisa Wisdom, progressive Jewish leader, to run Office to Combat AntisemitismMamdani appoints head of progressive Jewish group to lead antisemitism office

Mayor Mamdani expressed confidence in Wisdom's ability to lead, stating, “Phylisa is a respected leader and powerful voice in the fight against antisemitism in New York City.” Wisdom herself remarked on the importance of her role, emphasizing her commitment to ensuring Jewish safety and belonging in the city. However, her critics, including former office director Moshe Davis, have voiced concerns about her suitability for the position, suggesting that her appointment may be more symbolic than operational.

Mamdani appoints Phylisa Wisdom, progressive Jewish leader, to run Office to Combat Antisemitism

As Wisdom steps into her new role, she faces the challenge of navigating the complex landscape of Jewish politics in New York City. Her ability to foster dialogue among diverse Jewish communities while addressing rising antisemitism will be closely monitored. The City Council has also established a task force to combat antisemitism, which may lead to further collaboration or tension with the mayor's office.

Mamdani taps progressive Jewish leader to head Office to Combat Antisemitism, sparking controversy

While some Jewish leaders support Wisdom's appointment, others remain deeply concerned about her past affiliations and statements regarding Israel and antisemitism. The divide within the community reflects broader tensions regarding how best to address antisemitism in a city where Jews are disproportionately targeted in hate crimes. The effectiveness of Wisdom's leadership will likely depend on her ability to bridge these divides and establish trust across the spectrum of Jewish opinion.

Mamdani taps progressive Jewish leader to head Office to Combat Antisemitism, sparking controversy