Full Breakdown
Santa Monica Restaurant's Pest Problem Linked to Nearby Homeless Shelter
2/9/2026, 3:52:33 AM
Core Event: Health Violations at Elephante Restaurant
Elephante, a high-end restaurant in Santa Monica, California, was temporarily closed on January 20, 2026, due to health code violations related to a vermin infestation. The closure followed a routine inspection that revealed seven violations, including significant breaches concerning the presence of rodents and insects, resulting in a "B" rating from health officials. The restaurant was allowed to reopen two days later.
Background & Context: The Role of Step Up on Second
The controversy surrounding Elephante's health issues has intensified due to its proximity to Step Up on Second, a taxpayer-funded homeless shelter. This nonprofit organization provides supportive housing for individuals facing homelessness and receives substantial funding from the city of Santa Monica. Critics argue that the shelter's location near upscale establishments contributes to public health concerns, particularly regarding pest infestations.
Key Figures: Dr. Houman David Hemmati
Dr. Houman David Hemmati, an ophthalmologist and vocal critic of California's policies, has been particularly outspoken about the situation. In a video shared on social media platform X, he directly linked the pest problem at Elephante to the nearby homeless shelter, stating, “Put a homeless shelter right by the nicest restaurants, and you’re going to get rats and roaches.” Hemmati's comments reflect a broader concern among some residents regarding the impact of homelessness services on local businesses.
Official Statements & Responses
While Dr. Hemmati has publicly criticized the shelter's placement, Elephante has not issued any statements regarding these claims. The health department's inspection report did not specify the source of the vermin infestation, leaving the connection between the restaurant's issues and the shelter open to interpretation.
Criticism & Opposition: Perspectives on Homeless Shelters
The criticism directed at Step Up on Second highlights a contentious debate in Santa Monica regarding the placement of homeless shelters. Supporters of the shelter argue that it provides essential services to vulnerable populations, while detractors, like Hemmati, contend that its location adversely affects local businesses and public health. This divide underscores the challenges cities face in balancing the needs of homeless individuals with those of the broader community.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
There is currently no official confirmation linking the vermin infestation at Elephante directly to the homeless shelter. The health department's findings did not attribute the source of the pests to the shelter, and Elephante has not publicly addressed the claims made by Dr. Hemmati. This lack of clarity leaves room for speculation and differing opinions on the matter.
Verbatim Quotes
- “This is called Step Up on Second, a city taxpayer funded homeless shelter,” — Dr. Houman David Hemmati, Ophthalmologist
- “Stench all the time, flies everywhere …” — Dr. Houman David Hemmati, Ophthalmologist
- “Dozens of homeless people here at our expense, located right in the heart of downtown Santa Monica, a block from the beach, right by the ocean, and they’re housed right here. Stench all the time, flies everywhere … Put a homeless shelter right by the nicest restaurants, and you’re going to get rats and roaches.” — Dr. Houman David Hemmati, Ophthalmologist
