Progressive Democrats Propose Resolution to Replace Monroe Doctrine

A coalition of progressive Democrats, led by Representative Nydia Velázquez (D-N.Y.), has introduced a resolution aimed at discarding the Monroe Doctrine in favor of a new foreign policy framework for the Western Hemisphere. This initiative seeks to establish a policy based on mutual cooperation and respect, contrasting sharply with the current administration's approach, which is characterized by what is termed the "Don-Roe Doctrine." Velázquez emphasized the urgency of this resolution, citing shared challenges such as drug trafficking, mass migration, and climate change that require collaborative solutions rather than coercive tactics.

The Hill

The resolution articulates a clear rejection of U.S. interference in Latin America, asserting that the failure to officially renounce the Monroe Doctrine has perpetuated detrimental policies for over two centuries. It calls for the U.S. Department of State to formally declare that the Monroe Doctrine is no longer part of American policy toward Latin America and the Caribbean. In its place, the resolution proposes a "New Good Neighbor" policy aimed at fostering improved relations and effective cooperation with all nations in the region.

The Hill

Key provisions of the resolution include:

The Hill

• Ending the Trump administration's blockade on Cuba.

The Hill

• Reasserting Congressional control over tariffs.

The Hill

• Reinforcing respect for the sovereignty of other nations in foreign policy decisions.

The Hill

• Ensuring Congressional oversight in cases of extraconstitutional power transfers.

The Hill

• Declassifying information related to past U.S. covert operations that involved coups and human rights abuses.

The Hill

• Promoting reforms in economic policy and development through bilateral and multilateral engagements.

The Hill

Critics of the Trump administration's approach argue that the so-called "Don-Roe Doctrine" represents an aggressive extension of outdated policies that have historically failed to benefit the U.S. or its neighbors. Velázquez stated, “What this administration proudly calls the ‘Donroe Doctrine’ is really just a more aggressive version of the same policy that has failed the United States and our neighbors for over two centuries.” This sentiment reflects a broader discontent among progressive lawmakers regarding the administration's tactics in the region, which they view as a return to "gunboat diplomacy."

The Hill

The resolution has garnered support from other progressive representatives, including Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), Greg Casar (D-Texas), and Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.). While the resolution is unlikely to advance in the Republican-controlled House, it serves as a foundational blueprint for a progressive foreign policy that seeks to counter the current administration's vision for Latin America.

The Hill

As the resolution unfolds, it may prompt discussions about U.S. foreign policy in the region, particularly regarding the implications of the proposed "New Good Neighbor" policy. The progressive Democrats aim to reshape the narrative around U.S.-Latin American relations, focusing on cooperation rather than dominance.

The Hill