The Rise of the Emotional Economy in China: Scolding as Therapy

In China, a new trend has emerged within the emotional economy, where young individuals, often self-identified as “love-brained,” seek guidance through public scolding from influencers. This phenomenon has gained traction on social media platforms, particularly through live-streaming sessions, where influencers provide blunt, often harsh advice to those seeking emotional support.

South China Morning Post

The term “love-brained” describes individuals who become overly infatuated, often leading to poor decision-making in romantic relationships. This trend has resonated with many young people in China, particularly those from affluent backgrounds who find themselves in unreciprocated love situations. The emotional release provided by public scolding is seen as a form of therapy, albeit unconventional.

South China Morning Post

Influencers like Taozai have become central figures in this emotional economy. During a live-stream, Taozai confronted a young woman who was infatuated with an older, less affluent man. Rather than offering comfort, Taozai's response highlighted the young woman's perceived biases against those of lower socioeconomic status, stating, “Not only do you have a ‘love brain’, you also subconsciously discriminate against people with lower education and the poor.” This approach, while jarring, has attracted a significant following, as many viewers find solace in the candidness of such interactions.

South China Morning Post

The rise of scolding services reflects a broader cultural shift in how young people in China process emotions and relationships. Instead of seeking traditional forms of therapy, many are turning to public platforms for validation and guidance. This trend raises questions about the effectiveness of such methods and the societal implications of public emotional expression.

South China Morning Post

Critics argue that the scolding approach may lead to further emotional distress rather than healing. The public nature of these interactions can be seen as a form of humiliation, potentially exacerbating feelings of inadequacy among participants. Mental health professionals caution that while some may find relief in this format, it could also reinforce negative self-perceptions and societal biases.

South China Morning Post

Mental health experts have expressed mixed views on the trend. Some acknowledge the appeal of candid advice in a society where emotional vulnerability is often stigmatized, while others warn against the potential harm of public scolding. The consensus suggests a need for balance between honest feedback and supportive guidance.

South China Morning Post

• “Not only do you have a ‘love brain’, you also subconsciously discriminate against people with lower education and the poor. You discriminate against others, and others will not love you. This is karma; you deserve it.” — Taozai, Influencer

South China Morning Post

As the emotional economy continues to evolve, it remains to be seen how these scolding services will impact mental health discourse in China. The trend may prompt further exploration of alternative emotional support systems, potentially leading to a broader acceptance of unconventional therapeutic practices.

South China Morning Post