Story perspectives

Judge Faces Removal Hearing After Controversial NZ First Event

2/11/2026

Summary

Story summary

Judge Ema Aitken, a New Zealand judge, faces a hearing to decide if she should be removed over conduct at a November 2024 NZ First event.
Aitken allegedly yelled at party leader Winston Peters, claiming he lied.
Her husband confronted MP Casey Costello.
Judicial Conduct Panel led by retired Judge Brendan Brown will assess the situation and report to the Attorney-General, who will make the final decision on removal.

History

Historical Context

In 2004, New Zealand initiated the Judicial Committee of Inquiry into the Conduct of Judges to bolster judicial accountability, resulting in clearer conduct guidelines. This inquiry reflects ongoing tensions between judicial independence and political discourse, highlighted by Judge Ema Aitken's recent confrontation with politician Winston Peters. The outcome of her hearing may influence public trust in the legal system and future judicial conduct cases.

1 of 2

Story summary

Judge Ema Aitken, a New Zealand judge, faces a hearing to decide if she should be removed over conduct at a November 2024 NZ First event.
Aitken allegedly yelled at party leader Winston Peters, claiming he lied.
Her husband confronted MP Casey Costello.
Judicial Conduct Panel led by retired Judge Brendan Brown will assess the situation and report to the Attorney-General, who will make the final decision on removal.

1 / 2