Reviving the Correspondence of George Bernard Shaw and Mrs. Patrick Campbell

"Dear Liar," a play by Jerome Kilty, explores the complex relationship between playwright George Bernard Shaw and actress Mrs. Patrick Campbell, who famously portrayed Eliza Doolittle in Shaw's "Pygmalion." Set against the backdrop of World War II, the narrative is drawn from their real-life correspondence, which was marked by both flirtation and conflict. The revival at the Jermyn Street Theatre features performances by Rachel Pickup and Alan Turkington, who embody these two larger-than-life personalities as they navigate their tumultuous relationship.

The Guardian

The first act of "Dear Liar" focuses on the challenges of staging "Pygmalion," showcasing the playful yet contentious exchanges between Shaw and Campbell. Their correspondence reveals a blend of professional negotiation and personal tension, with Campbell's spirited remarks juxtaposed against Shaw's domineering nature. The rehearsal process is fraught with difficulties, including Campbell's struggles with her Cockney accent and Shaw's demanding direction. Despite these challenges, the production ultimately succeeds, reflecting the intricate dynamics of their partnership.

The Guardian

As the play progresses, the relationship between Shaw and Campbell deteriorates, particularly as they attempt to draw inspiration from their personal lives for their artistic endeavors. The narrative also touches on Shaw's pacifism and his emotional response to Campbell's loss during the war, adding layers of complexity to their interactions. The production, directed by Stella Powell-Jones, attempts to balance the historical context with modern interpretations of Campbell's character, who is increasingly viewed as a nuanced performer rather than a mere diva.

The Guardian

While the performances by Pickup and Turkington are noted for their emotional depth, the script itself has been described as somewhat antiquated, struggling to fully engage contemporary audiences. Critics have pointed out that the production occasionally falters in its delivery, with moments of genuine connection overshadowed by more strained exchanges. The visual design, featuring cloud-stippled curtains and playful costumes, adds a whimsical touch but does not entirely compensate for the script's limitations.

The Guardian

In summary, "Dear Liar" presents a fascinating glimpse into the minds of two iconic figures in theatre history. Although Kilty's play captures the essence of their correspondence, it struggles to resonate fully with modern audiences. The revival serves as a reminder of the enduring impact of Shaw and Campbell's relationship, even as it grapples with the challenges of presenting their story in a contemporary context.

The Guardian