CBP Engages Clearview AI for Enhanced Face Recognition Capabilities

United States Customs and Border Protection (CBP) has entered into a contract worth $225,000 for a year of access to Clearview AI, a facial recognition technology that utilizes a database of over 60 billion images scraped from the internet. This agreement extends the use of Clearview AI to CBP's intelligence divisions, including the National Targeting Center, as part of a broader initiative to identify and dismantle perceived security threats.

Wired Magazine

The Clearview AI tools are intended for "tactical targeting" and "strategic counter-network analysis," suggesting their integration into the daily operations of CBP analysts rather than being limited to specific investigations. The contract raises concerns regarding the types of images that agents may upload, the potential inclusion of U.S. citizens in searches, and the retention period for uploaded images and search results. CBP has not clarified these aspects, which has led to increased scrutiny from civil liberties groups and lawmakers.

Wired Magazine

The deployment of Clearview AI comes amid growing criticism regarding the use of facial recognition technology in federal enforcement operations. Senator Ed Markey has introduced legislation aimed at prohibiting the use of such technology by CBP and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), citing a lack of transparency, public consent, and clear limits on biometric surveillance practices. Critics argue that these technologies are becoming routine tools for intelligence gathering rather than being reserved for specific investigative purposes.

Wired Magazine

Recent evaluations by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) have highlighted significant limitations in facial recognition systems, including those offered by Clearview AI. Testing revealed that while these systems perform well with high-quality images, they struggle with less controlled environments, resulting in error rates exceeding 20%. This raises concerns about the reliability of the technology, particularly when used in investigative settings where human review is necessary to confirm matches.

Wired Magazine

There is a discrepancy in CBP's public privacy documentation, which states that the Traveler Verification System does not utilize information from commercial sources or publicly available data. However, it is anticipated that Clearview AI's access may be linked to CBP's Automated Targeting System, which incorporates biometric galleries and enforcement records, including those from ICE operations. This inconsistency raises questions about the integration of Clearview AI within existing systems and its implications for privacy.

Wired Magazine

• “The agreement anticipates analysts handling sensitive personal data, including biometric identifiers such as face images, and requires nondisclosure agreements for contractors who have access.” — Source

Wired Magazine

• “The testing underscores a central limitation of the technology: NIST found that face-search systems cannot reduce false matches without also increasing the risk that the systems fail to recognize the correct person.” — Source

Wired Magazine

• “Civil liberties groups and lawmakers have questioned whether face-search tools are being deployed as routine intelligence infrastructure, rather than limited investigative aids, and whether safeguards have kept pace with expansion.” — Source

Wired Magazine

• “Last week, Senator Ed Markey introduced legislation that would bar ICE and CBP from using face recognition technology altogether, citing concerns that biometric surveillance is being embedded without clear limits, transparency, or public consent.” — Source

Wired Magazine

This contract with Clearview AI marks a significant step in the use of facial recognition technology by federal agencies, raising important questions about privacy, reliability, and the future of biometric surveillance in the United States.

Wired Magazine