Story perspectives

Trump's Immigration Strategy Faces 373 Judicial Setbacks

2/13/2026

Center

Trump's Deportation Defeat

U.S. President Donald Trump faced broad judicial opposition, with 373 rulings opposing the mass detention strategy for immigrants.
Judges from blue and red states dismissed the administration's deportation efforts, including 44 Trump-appointed judges who ruled against it.
Judges opposed the strategy in at least 3,500 cases, with only 150 rulings in the administration's favor.
The 5th Circuit recently sided with the minority, potentially sending the case to the Supreme Court.

Left

Fifth Circuit's Detention Expansion

The Fifth Circuit expanded authority to detain undocumented immigrants in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, in Buenrostro-Mendez v. Bondi.
The ruling contradicts most federal judges who rejected the administration's immigration interpretation.
Critics warn the ruling could prolong detentions without bond hearings.
The Supreme Court's Republican majority may wait months to resolve the case and allow continued administration practices.
Legal experts warn the decision could severely limit immigrants' rights to seek release.

1 of 2

Trump's Deportation Defeat

U.S. President Donald Trump faced broad judicial opposition, with 373 rulings opposing the mass detention strategy for immigrants.
Judges from blue and red states dismissed the administration's deportation efforts, including 44 Trump-appointed judges who ruled against it.
Judges opposed the strategy in at least 3,500 cases, with only 150 rulings in the administration's favor.
The 5th Circuit recently sided with the minority, potentially sending the case to the Supreme Court.

1 / 2