Irvine Company Proposes Nature Park Amid Controversy Over Oak Creek Golf Course Development

The Irvine Company has announced plans to transform the Oak Creek Golf Course into the city’s largest nature park, proposing to allocate over 50 acres of the 193-acre site for open, natural space. This initiative aims to enhance the existing Jeffrey Open Space Trail, creating a continuous pathway between the Limestone Canyon Nature Preserve and the Quail Hill Nature Preserve. The proposed features of the nature park include bridges, creeks, meadows, nature trails, and a nature center for community events. Jeff Davis, Senior Vice President of the Irvine Company, emphasized that this development will significantly expand Irvine’s park system, providing additional recreational opportunities.

Orange County Register

In conjunction with the nature park proposal, the Irvine Company has reduced its previous housing plan, which sought to build 3,100 homes on the golf course. The City Council had previously halted this proposal due to concerns that it would violate a 1988 voter-approved initiative designating the golf course as open space. The council's decision was influenced by a residents' group, the Committee to Protect All Irvine Open Space, which is now pushing for a new initiative that would require voter approval for any developments on land designated as open space.

Orange County Register

City Attorney Jeffrey Melching clarified that the City Council is not legally obligated to seek voter approval for changes to the open space designation, stating that the original initiative did not amend the General Plan as required. This legal interpretation has sparked debate among residents, many of whom believe the initiative was intended to permanently preserve the Oak Creek area. Rolf Parkes, a spokesperson for the residents' group, argues that the proposed development violates the 1988 initiative and necessitates voter consent, citing concerns over increased traffic and community impact.

Orange County Register

Councilmember Kathleen Treseder, who previously advocated for a public vote on the housing project, indicated she would support the development if it meets the city’s affordable housing requirements, regardless of voter input.

Orange County Register

The Irvine Company is actively seeking community feedback on its plans, with officials aiming to present the proposed development to the City Council by early spring. Residents can participate in planning sessions and provide input through the city's dedicated platform.

Orange County Register

• “This planned nature park will significantly expand Irvine’s nationally ranked park system, with additional recreation opportunities in the center of Irvine.” — Jeff Davis, Senior Vice President, Irvine Company

Orange County Register

• “and the inordinate amount of traffic that exists today. Putting thousands of homes in the area, nothing’s going to move, how are people going to get in and out?” — Rolf Parkes, Spokesperson, Committee to Protect All Irvine Open Space

Orange County Register

• “And so even if they’re developing part of that, I think that they are holding to the open space initiative under those circumstances.” — Kathleen Treseder, Councilmember

Orange County Register

There is a discrepancy regarding the legal obligations of the City Council concerning voter approval for developments on designated open space. While some residents believe the council is required to seek approval, the City Attorney maintains that it is not legally bound to do so. Additionally, the exact number of homes to be included in the revised housing proposal remains under study.

Orange County Register