Story perspectives

NFL Blocks Player Report Cards, Sparking Criticism from Stars

2/13/2026

Summary

Story summary

The NFL barred the NFL Players Association from publishing its team report cards after a grievance ruling found the reports violated the collective bargaining agreement.
The NFL argued the report cards ranking teams by player feedback were misleading and favored the union's interests.
The NFLPA will continue gathering feedback via an independent survey.
Former players Cam Jordan and J.J. Watt criticized the decision, saying it undermines accountability and workplace standards.

History

Historical Context

In 2011, the NFL and the NFL Players Association (NFLPA) reached a collective bargaining agreement after a contentious period marked by the owners' decision to opt out of the previous agreement in 2008. This led to an uncapped season in 2010, limiting player rights and free agency. Current disputes over player feedback mechanisms reflect ongoing tensions regarding accountability and management control within the league.

1 of 2

Story summary

The NFL barred the NFL Players Association from publishing its team report cards after a grievance ruling found the reports violated the collective bargaining agreement.
The NFL argued the report cards ranking teams by player feedback were misleading and favored the union's interests.
The NFLPA will continue gathering feedback via an independent survey.
Former players Cam Jordan and J.J. Watt criticized the decision, saying it undermines accountability and workplace standards.

1 / 2