Full Breakdown
Derek Carr's Potential NFL Comeback: Analyzing Landing Spots
2/13/2026, 10:18:40 PM
Derek Carr's Return to the NFL
Derek Carr, the former New Orleans Saints quarterback, has confirmed his openness to coming out of retirement after a year away from the NFL. During a recent episode of his podcast, "Home Grown with David & Derek Carr," he expressed a desire to return, contingent on two main conditions: he must be healthy and he wants to play for a team capable of contending for a Super Bowl. Carr retired in May 2025 due to a significant shoulder injury, but reports indicate he has since recovered and is throwing without limitations.
Possible Landing Spots for Carr
Several NFL teams have emerged as potential destinations for Carr if he decides to return:
Minnesota Vikings
The Vikings are seen as a strong candidate for Carr's services. After a disappointing season with J.J. McCarthy at the helm, the team is actively seeking a veteran quarterback to compete for the starting position. Carr's experience and past success could provide the stability Minnesota needs. The presence of talented receivers like Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison further enhances the appeal of this option.
Pittsburgh Steelers
The Steelers are also in the mix, particularly if Aaron Rodgers opts for retirement. With Mason Rudolph and Will Howard as current options, the Steelers may prefer a seasoned quarterback like Carr to lead the team while they search for a long-term solution. Carr's familiarity with veteran coaching could benefit Pittsburgh's offensive strategy.
Indianapolis Colts
The Colts present another intriguing possibility, especially given Daniel Jones' uncertain recovery from a torn Achilles. If Jones is unable to return by the start of the season, Carr could step in as a temporary starter. The Colts have a solid offensive lineup, including star running back Jonathan Taylor, which could facilitate Carr's success.
Kansas City Chiefs
The Chiefs could also be a viable option, particularly if Patrick Mahomes' recovery from a torn ACL does not progress as expected. Carr could serve as a bridge quarterback, allowing Mahomes the necessary time to heal while still competing for a championship.
Atlanta Falcons
The Falcons are considered a wildcard in this scenario. However, acquiring Carr would require a trade with the Saints, who hold his rights. The Falcons have expressed uncertainty about their current quarterback situation, making Carr an interesting option if they can navigate the trade complexities.
Official Statements & Responses
Derek Carr has reiterated his conditions for a potential return, stating, "Would I do it? Yes. Would I do it for anybody? Absolutely not. I’d have to be healthy and I would want a chance to win a Super Bowl." His brother, David Carr, emphasized that any team interested in Carr must be a serious playoff contender.
Criticism & Opposition
Some analysts express skepticism about Carr's ability to lead a team to a Super Bowl, citing his previous struggles in high-pressure situations. Additionally, the Saints' reluctance to facilitate a trade to a rival team like the Falcons could complicate matters.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
While Carr has confirmed his interest in returning, there is uncertainty regarding the Saints' willingness to trade him. Reports suggest that Carr's leverage in negotiations could influence the Saints' decision-making process, but the timeline for any potential trade remains unclear.
What's Next
As the offseason progresses, teams will likely continue to evaluate their quarterback situations, and Carr's status will remain a focal point. The upcoming weeks may reveal whether Carr will officially return to the NFL and, if so, which team he will join.
