Backlash Over Clark G. Gilbert's Appointment to LDS Church Leadership

Elder Clark G. Gilbert has been appointed as the newest member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS), a decision announced on Wednesday and followed by his ordination the next day. This appointment, made by LDS President Dallin H. Oaks, is significant as it places Gilbert in a lifetime role that combines spiritual leadership with substantial administrative authority, influencing church governance and policy for years to come. Gilbert previously served as the Church’s education commissioner and has been a General Authority Seventy since April 2021.

Newsweek

Gilbert's appointment has sparked considerable backlash, particularly on social media platforms like Reddit. Critics have raised concerns about his tenure as commissioner of the Church Educational System, where he was accused of enforcing strict policies at LDS-owned universities, fostering an environment of fear, and suppressing dissenting opinions. A notable criticism came from music professor Jason Bergman, who highlighted the negative impact of Gilbert's policies on students, particularly women and members of the LGBTQ community. Bergman stated, “I had LGBTQ students and saw how they suffered,” emphasizing the adverse effects of Gilbert's approach on marginalized groups.

Newsweek

Online discussions reflect a broader sentiment of unease regarding Gilbert's leadership style. One user remarked that he has “tirelessly created an environment of fear among both students and faculty,” suggesting that his appointment would perpetuate strict adherence to church doctrine. Another user described Gilbert as “another shining example of the worst Mormonism has to offer the world,” indicating a perception that his leadership may not align with progressive values within the church.

Newsweek

In contrast to the criticism, the LDS Church has praised Gilbert's professional background, emphasizing his commitment to mentoring students and his belief in the integration of faith and learning. Gilbert himself expressed gratitude for his new role, stating, “This is an amazing time to point people to the Savior Jesus Christ,” and underscoring the importance of finding joy and meaning through faith.

Newsweek

As Gilbert assumes his responsibilities as a “special witness” of Jesus Christ, he will play a crucial role in overseeing the global operations of the church. The Quorum of the Twelve Apostles will maintain its structure of 12 members following his ordination. The church's response to the ongoing backlash remains uncertain, with many observers keenly watching how Gilbert's leadership will shape the internal culture and policies of the LDS Church moving forward.

Newsweek

• “I had LGBTQ students and saw how they suffered,” — Jason Bergman, Music Professor

Newsweek

• “This is an amazing time to point people to the Savior Jesus Christ,” — Elder Clark G. Gilbert

Newsweek

While many critics have voiced concerns about Gilbert's leadership style and its implications for church culture, the LDS Church has not publicly addressed these criticisms in detail. The extent to which Gilbert's appointment will affect church policies and the internal dynamics of the LDS community remains to be seen.

Newsweek