Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

VAR Controversy Ignites FA Cup Debate After Newcastle's Match

2/16/2026

24 6 Full Breakdown

Summary

Shearer Critiques VAR

The debate over Video Assistant Referee (VAR) intensified in the FA Cup fourth round due to controversial officiating.
Newcastle United's match against Aston Villa highlighted the absence of VAR, leading to a missed offside goal and a handball no-call.
Alan Shearer, former Newcastle United striker, criticized referees for decisions without VAR.
Eddie Howe, Newcastle United manager, acknowledged VAR improves accuracy but harms game flow.

Summary

Sunderland Advances Cup

Sunderland advanced to the FA Cup fifth round for the first time since 2015 with a 1-0 win over Oxford United.
A contentious first-half penalty awarded to Sunderland sparked disagreement among fans and players.
Oxford United manager Matt Bloomfield criticized the officiating, citing recent poor decisions.
Sunderland's win marks a turnaround since last season's defeat to Oxford, as the club continues to build on Premier League form.

1 of 2

Shearer Critiques VAR

The debate over Video Assistant Referee (VAR) intensified in the FA Cup fourth round due to controversial officiating.
Newcastle United's match against Aston Villa highlighted the absence of VAR, leading to a missed offside goal and a handball no-call.
Alan Shearer, former Newcastle United striker, criticized referees for decisions without VAR.
Eddie Howe, Newcastle United manager, acknowledged VAR improves accuracy but harms game flow.

1 / 2