Disbarment of William McCall Calhoun, Jr. Following January 6 Insurrection

William McCall Calhoun, Jr., an attorney who participated in the January 6, 2021, insurrection at the U.S. Capitol, has been disbarred by the Georgia Supreme Court. This decision marks a significant stance by a Republican-led court against actions associated with the insurrection, emphasizing accountability for those involved in the violent takeover of the Capitol.

The Hill

Calhoun was among the first individuals to breach the Capitol, entering through a broken door and declaring, “This is it. We’re storming the Capitol.” He was recorded encouraging fellow rioters as they vandalized offices and sought out lawmakers, notably mentioning Speaker Nancy Pelosi. Following the events, Calhoun boasted on social media about the takeover, claiming, “We physically took control of the Capitol building in a hand to hand hostile takeover.” His actions led to his arrest and subsequent conviction on multiple charges, resulting in an 18-month prison sentence and the suspension of his law license.

The Hill

After serving his sentence, Calhoun petitioned for the restoration of his law license, arguing that a public reprimand would suffice. This petition received support from the state bar disciplinary counsel and a hearing officer, who recommended a lesser sanction. However, the Georgia Supreme Court unanimously rejected this recommendation, stating that pardons do not negate the underlying criminal acts that affect a lawyer's fitness to practice law. The court highlighted Calhoun's social media posts as evidence of his intent to participate in the insurrection, concluding that disbarment was the only appropriate response.

The Hill

The ruling by the Georgia Supreme Court underscores a broader recognition of the January 6 events as an insurrection rather than a mere protest. The court's decision reflects a commitment to uphold legal standards and accountability, even against the backdrop of political affiliations. This case serves as a precedent for how similar actions may be treated in the future, particularly regarding legal professionals involved in unlawful activities.

The Hill

While the ruling has been largely supported, some dissenting voices argue that the punishment may be too harsh, suggesting that a public reprimand could have sufficed. Critics of the disbarment emphasize the importance of rehabilitation and the potential for individuals to change after their actions.

The Hill

• “Pardons do not prevent disbarment for the underlying activity that formed the basis of the crime,” — Georgia Supreme Court

The Hill

• “This is it. We’re storming the Capitol.” — William McCall Calhoun, Jr.

The Hill

• “We physically took control of the Capitol building in a hand to hand hostile takeover. We occupied the Capitol and shut down the Government.” — William McCall Calhoun, Jr.

The Hill

The disbarment of William McCall Calhoun, Jr. illustrates a significant legal and moral stance against the actions taken during the January 6 insurrection, reinforcing the principle that accountability is essential in the legal profession.

The Hill