Trump’s Criticism of Herzog Over Netanyahu’s Pardon Request Sparks Controversy

U.S. President Donald Trump publicly criticized Israeli President Isaac Herzog for not yet granting a pardon to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who is embroiled in a corruption trial. During a press conference, Trump labeled Herzog as “disgraceful” and urged the Israeli public to shame him for his inaction regarding Netanyahu's pardon request, which is currently under review by the Attorney General's Office in Israel.

Times of IsraelHaaretz

Netanyahu has faced allegations of fraud, bribery, and breach of trust, leading to a protracted legal battle that has lasted nearly six years. The request for a pardon was formally submitted by Netanyahu’s legal team in late November 2025, but Herzog's office has clarified that no decision has been made, as the legal review process is still ongoing.

Times of Israel

In response to Trump’s remarks, Herzog’s office emphasized that the decision regarding the pardon would be made in accordance with the law and the best interests of Israel, free from external pressures. Herzog's statement noted, “Only upon completion of that process will President Herzog consider the request.” Furthermore, Herzog expressed appreciation for Trump’s contributions to Israel but insisted on the importance of maintaining Israel's sovereignty and rule of law.

Times of IsraelNew York Times

Netanyahu’s office distanced itself from Trump’s comments, asserting that the Prime Minister had no prior knowledge of Trump’s public criticism of Herzog. A source close to Herzog indicated that if Netanyahu had indeed encouraged Trump’s remarks, it would represent a significant breach of diplomatic norms.

Times of IsraelNew York Times

Trump's intervention into Israeli domestic affairs has drawn mixed reactions. Some Israeli officials expressed concern over the implications of Trump's comments, viewing them as an infringement on Israel's sovereignty. Conversely, staunch supporters of Netanyahu welcomed Trump's support, viewing it as a necessary push for the Prime Minister's pardon.

Times of Israel

There is ongoing debate regarding Herzog's authority to grant a pardon while Netanyahu's trial is still active. Some legal experts argue that Herzog may not have the legal capacity to issue a pardon at this stage. Initially, Herzog had planned to make a decision on the pardon request within weeks, but the urgency appears to have diminished as the trial continues.

Times of IsraelHaaretz

• “The people of Israel should really shame him” for not letting Mr.” — Donald Trump, U.S. President

New York Times

• “President Herzog deeply appreciates President Trump for his significant contribution to the State of Israel and its security. Israel is a sovereign state governed by the rule of law,” — Isaac Herzog, President of Israel

Times of Israel

• “If Netanyahu had a hand in this, it is a red line that has been crossed.” — Source close to Isaac Herzog

Times of Israel

This situation highlights the complexities of U.S.-Israel relations, particularly regarding internal political matters, and raises questions about the balance of influence between the two nations.

New York Times