I Can Only Imagine 2: A Sequel's Reception and Narrative

_I Can Only Imagine 2_, released on February 20, 2026, serves as a sequel to the 2018 film _I Can Only Imagine_, which chronicled Bart Millard's journey in writing the titular song inspired by his relationship with his abusive father. The sequel shifts focus to the backstory of MercyMe's 2017 hit "Even If," exploring Bart's struggles as a successful musician and father. John Michael Finley reprises his role as Bart, who now faces emotional turmoil despite his band's success, including writer's block and the challenges of parenting his son, Sam, who has type 1 diabetes.

Hollywood Reporter

The film introduces Tim Timmons, portrayed by Milo Ventimiglia, who joins MercyMe's national tour as an opening act. Timmons brings humor to the narrative but also faces his own battle with cancer, adding depth to the storyline. The film's plot revolves around Bart's attempts to connect with his son while grappling with his past. The climax features Bart premiering "Even If" at a concert, symbolizing his personal growth and reconciliation with his son.

Hollywood Reporter

Critics have largely described _I Can Only Imagine 2_ as a lackluster sequel that feels more like a cash grab than a meaningful continuation of the story. The film has been criticized for its narrative shortcomings, particularly the lack of compelling conflict since Bart had already reconciled with his father in the previous film. The comedic elements brought by Ventimiglia's character were noted as highlights, yet the overall execution was deemed laborious and dull.

Hollywood Reporter

The film's creators, including co-directors Andrew Erwin and Brent McCorkle, aimed to explore deeper themes of faith and resilience through Bart's journey. However, the reception suggests that their efforts did not resonate with audiences as intended, leading to a perception of the film as unnecessary.

Hollywood Reporter

Critics have pointed out that the film struggles to maintain viewer interest due to its repetitive themes and lack of engaging conflict. The portrayal of Bart's relationship with his son has been described as unconvincing, particularly regarding Sam's health issues, which detracts from the emotional weight of the narrative. Furthermore, the film's ending, while visually appealing, has been criticized for its deviation from factual events.

Hollywood Reporter

• “Laborious and dull, I Can Only Imagine 2 only comes to life in the comedic scenes featuring Ventimiglia, who buries his handsomeness in a buzz-cut, full beard, and Buddy Holly-style glasses to resemble Timmons.” — Hollywood Reporter

Hollywood Reporter

• “But their efforts are not enough to save this unnecessary sequel that smacks of a cash grab.” — Hollywood Reporter

Hollywood Reporter

_I Can Only Imagine 2_ attempts to build on the success of its predecessor by delving into new themes of faith and family. However, the film's critical reception highlights significant narrative flaws and a lack of engaging content, raising questions about the necessity of its sequel status.

Hollywood Reporter