Story perspectives

Missing Tucson Woman, 84, Abducted Amid Misinformation Crisis

2/18/2026

Center

Guthrie Abduction Investigation

Nancy Guthrie, 84, was reported missing from her Tucson home February 1, 2026.
Investigators believe she was abducted due to limited mobility and assistance needs.
Security footage shows a masked person tampering with the door camera before her disappearance, per State Rep. Alma Hernandez.
A DNA sample from a discarded glove near her home matched the suspect's gloves.
The case drew media attention, including true-crime livestreamers, prompting criticism of misinformation.

Left

Carmona Arrested After Murder

Raymond Isaac Carmona, 20, was arrested after an AMBER Alert following the murder of his mother, Andrea Colgrove, 63, on January 31, 2023.
Carmona allegedly fatally stabbed Colgrove at their Mansfield home before abducting his four-year-old nephew in her vehicle.
Police found Colgrove unresponsive, ruling her death a homicide.
The AMBER Alert led to the recovery of the child and Carmona's capture in Missouri.
He faces charges of murder, aggravated kidnapping, and theft of property, with a bond set at over $1 million, and is scheduled for court on February 23, 2023.

1 of 2

Guthrie Abduction Investigation

Nancy Guthrie, 84, was reported missing from her Tucson home February 1, 2026.
Investigators believe she was abducted due to limited mobility and assistance needs.
Security footage shows a masked person tampering with the door camera before her disappearance, per State Rep. Alma Hernandez.
A DNA sample from a discarded glove near her home matched the suspect's gloves.
The case drew media attention, including true-crime livestreamers, prompting criticism of misinformation.

1 / 2