Story perspectives

Judges Now Allowed to Respond to Criticism, Sparking Controversy

2/19/2026

Summary

Story summary

The U.S. Judicial Conference issued ethics guidelines allowing judges to comment on perceived illegitimate criticism.
Critics say the change undermines integrity and risks eroding public trust.
Historically, judges kept a non-partisan stance, but judges appointed by President Barack Obama have blurred lines.
Notably, Judge Tanya Chutkan and others have commented on U.S. President Donald Trump.
Observers warn the guidelines could invite more political commentary, undermining judicial neutrality.

1 of 1

Story summary

The U.S. Judicial Conference issued ethics guidelines allowing judges to comment on perceived illegitimate criticism.
Critics say the change undermines integrity and risks eroding public trust.
Historically, judges kept a non-partisan stance, but judges appointed by President Barack Obama have blurred lines.
Notably, Judge Tanya Chutkan and others have commented on U.S. President Donald Trump.
Observers warn the guidelines could invite more political commentary, undermining judicial neutrality.