Story perspectives

Barnes & Noble's CEO Sparks Debate Over Bookstore Identity

2/19/2026

Summary

Story summary

Barnes & Noble CEO James Daunt criticized Volumes Bookcafe as lacking features of a full bookstore.
The remarks sparked discussions in Wicker Park about what defines a true bookstore.
Many in Wicker Park expressed sorrow over Volumes' closing, noting its community role.
Volumes' owners reported a significant sales drop after Barnes & Noble opened nearby.
An Author Farewell Event underscored the emotional impact, with supporters noting independent bookstores' vital local role.

History

Historical Context

The decline of independent bookstores in the U.S. began in the late 20th century, as major chains like Barnes & Noble expanded and online retailers like Amazon emerged. By 2011, over 300 independents closed, reflecting a 30% sales drop. This trend continues in Wicker Park, where Volumes Bookcafe's closure raises concerns about the community role of local bookstores amid increasing corporate dominance.

1 of 2

Story summary

Barnes & Noble CEO James Daunt criticized Volumes Bookcafe as lacking features of a full bookstore.
The remarks sparked discussions in Wicker Park about what defines a true bookstore.
Many in Wicker Park expressed sorrow over Volumes' closing, noting its community role.
Volumes' owners reported a significant sales drop after Barnes & Noble opened nearby.
An Author Farewell Event underscored the emotional impact, with supporters noting independent bookstores' vital local role.

1 / 2