Full Breakdown
Tensions Rise Between Tom Homan and Kristi Noem Over Immigration Enforcement
2/20/2026, 11:52:24 PM
Background on the Conflict
The ongoing feud between Tom Homan, President Donald Trump's appointed border czar, and Kristi Noem, the Governor of South Dakota, has intensified following recent incidents involving federal immigration agents. Their rivalry has been marked by public disputes over statements and actions related to immigration enforcement, particularly in the wake of fatal shootings involving federal agents.
Core Event: Dispute Over Immigration Agent Accountability
During a recent appearance on CNN, Homan was questioned about the Department of Homeland Security's integrity, specifically regarding allegations of lying by federal agents. This inquiry was prompted by Noem's controversial claims about the shooting of Alex Pretti, a 37-year-old ICU nurse, who was shot by immigration agents in Minneapolis on January 24, 2026. Noem had asserted that Pretti was brandishing a gun, a statement contradicted by video evidence showing the gun was holstered at the time of the shooting.
Homan refrained from commenting directly on the investigation into Pretti's death but criticized Noem's statements, stating, “I don’t know what information the secretary had when she made those statements. I can tell you I didn’t make those statements.” He emphasized the importance of a thorough investigation and accountability for any violations of law or policy.
Official Statements & Responses
Homan reiterated that any agents found to have acted outside of policy would be subject to internal investigations. He noted, “If they committed a crime, then they need to be held accountable,” referencing ongoing inquiries into agents who may have lied under oath regarding their actions. Homan also mentioned that the U.S. Attorney's office is involved in these investigations, indicating a serious approach to accountability within the agency.
In response to questions about Border Patrol Commander Greg Bovino, who was previously found to have lied in a deposition, Homan stated that accountability lies with Noem, as she oversees the Border Patrol. He remarked, “What people need to understand is CBP and ICE do not report to me. They report to Kristi Noem, and she’ll hold these officers responsible.”
Criticism & Opposition
Critics of Noem's statements have highlighted the discrepancies between her claims and the available evidence, arguing that her rhetoric could undermine public trust in law enforcement agencies. The backlash against her comments has been significant, particularly given the serious nature of the incidents involving federal agents.
What's Next
As investigations continue into the actions of federal immigration agents, the tensions between Homan and Noem are likely to persist. The outcomes of these inquiries may further influence the dynamics of their rivalry and the broader discourse on immigration enforcement in the United States.
Verbatim Quotes
- “I said from day one, in any of these shootings, that I would not comment on them until the investigation is finished by the FBI, internal affairs. That's the way it should be. We shouldn't prejudge it and, look, I don't know what information the secretary had when she made those statements. I can tell you I didn't make those statements. I would never you know, I don't want influence investigation. I have an opinion, but I won't share my opinion because I want a thorough investigation, and if people violated the law, if people violated policy, again, they need to be held accountable.” — Tom Homan, Border Czar
- “If they committed a crime, then they need to be held accountable,” — Tom Homan, Border Czar
- “What people need to understand CBP and ICE do not report to me. They report to Kristi Noem, and she'll hold these officers responsible.” — Tom Homan, Border Czar
