Full Breakdown
Judge Denies Immunity for Weldon Boyd in Scott Spivey Shooting Case
2/21/2026, 6:24:40 AM
Overview of the Case
A South Carolina circuit court judge has denied Weldon Boyd's request for immunity under the state's "Stand Your Ground" law in connection with the fatal shooting of Scott Spivey on September 9, 2023. Judge Eugene C. Griffith, Jr. ruled that Boyd's testimony lacked credibility and that his actions prior to the incident undermined his claim of lawful self-defense. The ruling allows the wrongful death lawsuit filed by Spivey’s estate to proceed to trial.
Key Events and Testimonies
The four-day hearing focused on the events leading to Spivey’s death, which occurred during a road rage incident along Camp Swamp Road in Horry County. Boyd and his passenger, Kenneth "Bradley" Williams, acknowledged firing the shots that killed Spivey but contended they acted in self-defense. The court heard conflicting accounts of the confrontation, including whether Spivey pointed a gun at Boyd and Williams before they opened fire.
During the hearing, forensic evidence was presented, including testimony from pathologist Angelina Phillips, who determined that Spivey was shot in the back, suggesting he may have been facing Boyd at the time. Toxicology reports indicated Spivey had a blood alcohol concentration of 0.13%, raising questions about his state during the incident.
Boyd's emotional testimony included claims that he followed Spivey to relay his location to 911 after Spivey allegedly pointed a gun at Williams. However, Judge Griffith highlighted inconsistencies in Boyd's statements and noted troubling post-incident communications that suggested efforts to align their narratives.
Official Statements & Responses
Judge Griffith emphasized the importance of credibility in his ruling, stating, “I really question the credibility of Weldon Boyd.” He noted that while Spivey exhibited "foolish behavior," it did not justify Boyd's actions, which included pursuing Spivey at high speeds. The judge remarked, “Foolish behavior don’t require you to foolishly act yourself.”
The Spivey family expressed relief at the ruling, with Jennifer Foley, Spivey’s sister, stating, “It’s been a long, long war... I just wish it felt better.”
Criticism & Opposition
Critics of Boyd's actions, including the Spivey family’s attorney Mark Tinsley, argued that Boyd's decision to pursue Spivey constituted aggression, undermining his self-defense claim. Tinsley pointed out that Boyd had previously described the encounter as a "chase," contradicting his assertion that he was merely following Spivey.
Additionally, the handling of evidence by law enforcement has been scrutinized, with allegations of mishandling during the initial investigation. The Horry County Police Department faced criticism for failing to separate witnesses and for the overall management of the crime scene.
What's Next
The denial of immunity for Boyd allows the wrongful death lawsuit to advance, while the status of Kenneth "Bradley" Williams' immunity request remains undecided. Judge Griffith indicated he would take additional time to consider Williams' case, which could have significant implications for both men as the civil litigation progresses. The Spivey family’s pursuit of justice continues as they seek accountability for their loss.
Verbatim Quotes
- “I really question the credibility of Weldon Boyd.” — Judge Eugene C. Griffith, Jr.
- “It’s been ‘no, no, no’ for two years. I just wish it felt better.” — Jennifer Foley, Spivey’s sister.
