Cillian Murphy's Missed Opportunity in Tron: Ares

In the development of *Tron: Ares*, concept art by Phil Saunders has surfaced, showcasing an early idea to bring back Cillian Murphy as a new version of the character Sark. Murphy, who portrayed Ed Dillinger Jr. in *Tron: Legacy* (2010), was initially considered for a more significant role in the sequel. Saunders indicated that the artwork was intended to entice Murphy to reprise his role, but ultimately, he declined the offer. The concept of a Dillinger becoming Sark was then transferred to Ed Jr.'s son, Julian, played by Evan Peters. In the film's post-credit scene, Julian discovers the Sark disc and dons the armor, setting the stage for potential future developments.

GizmodoCillian Murphy’s Cancelled Return in Disney’s $142M Sci-Fi Sequel Revealed in New Art (& We Wish It Had Happened)

*Tron: Legacy*, released in 2010, received mixed reviews, holding a 51% rating from critics and a 64% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics noted the film's stunning visual effects but criticized its narrative depth and character development. Commentators described it as "beautifully filmed" yet "shallow," with many viewers expressing disappointment in its storytelling and pacing. The film's failure to resonate with audiences raised questions about the potential impact of Murphy's involvement in a sequel.

Cillian Murphy’s Cancelled Return in Disney’s $142M Sci-Fi Sequel Revealed in New Art (& We Wish It Had Happened)

Phil Saunders, the concept designer, reflected on his work for *Tron: Legacy*, stating, “One of the first things Production Designer Darren Gilford asked me to tackle on Tron: Legacy was a quick illustration of Cillian Murphy as the new Sark.” He expressed hope that the artwork did not influence Murphy's decision to not return. Despite the artistic efforts, the film's reception suggests that even Murphy's acclaimed acting skills might not have salvaged the overall experience.

Cillian Murphy’s Cancelled Return in Disney’s $142M Sci-Fi Sequel Revealed in New Art (& We Wish It Had Happened)

The critical response to *Tron: Legacy* highlighted its failure to deliver a compelling story, with some reviews labeling it as "thin" in its portrayal of themes related to oppression. Critics pointed out that the film's aesthetic appeal could not compensate for its narrative shortcomings. One viewer remarked, “Cool visuals, but very poor storytelling,” reflecting a common sentiment among audiences.

Cillian Murphy’s Cancelled Return in Disney’s $142M Sci-Fi Sequel Revealed in New Art (& We Wish It Had Happened)

• “One of the first things Production Designer Darren Gilford asked me to tackle on Tron: Legacy was a quick illustration of Cillian Murphy as the new Sark. I think it was meant to lure him to the production to reprise his role as the junior Dillinger. Given his absence from the movie, I hope this illo isn’t the reason he passed!” — Phil Saunders, Concept Designer

Cillian Murphy’s Cancelled Return in Disney’s $142M Sci-Fi Sequel Revealed in New Art (& We Wish It Had Happened)

• “Tron: Legacy proves that with so many examples of oppression in fiction and reality, this movie had to come from a special place to be thinner in its spin on an evil leader and his forces than the last season of Game of Thrones,” — Sarah Vincent, Critic

Cillian Murphy’s Cancelled Return in Disney’s $142M Sci-Fi Sequel Revealed in New Art (& We Wish It Had Happened)

While the future of *Tron: Ares* remains uncertain, the concept art and character developments suggest that there are still creative avenues to explore within the *Tron* universe. The potential for Julian's character to evolve into a new Sark may provide a fresh narrative direction, although the likelihood of Murphy's return appears slim.

Gizmodo