"Marty Supreme" Ties BAFTA Record for Most Losses in a Single Night

At the recent British Academy Film Awards (BAFTA), Josh Safdie’s film “Marty Supreme” garnered an unwanted distinction by tying the record for the most losses in a single night, finishing with 0 wins out of 11 nominations. The film, which had entered the ceremony with high expectations, particularly for leading actor Timothée Chalamet, faced a surprising defeat when Chalamet lost to Robert Aramayo for his performance in the drama “I Swear.”

Variety Magazine

“Marty Supreme” joins the ranks of “Women in Love” (1969) and “Finding Neverland” (2004), both of which also went winless with 11 nominations at the BAFTAs. Notably, both films eventually secured an Oscar win in subsequent ceremonies, highlighting that a poor showing at the BAFTAs does not necessarily predict failure at the Oscars.

Variety Magazine

Despite the BAFTA setback, “Marty Supreme” remains a significant contender in the ongoing awards season. The film is nominated for nine Academy Awards, although it did not receive nominations for supporting actress and makeup and hairstyling at the BAFTAs. The final voting for the Oscars will take place from February 26 to March 5, with the ceremony scheduled for March 15, hosted by Conan O’Brien.

Variety Magazine

The BAFTA results may impact the film's momentum leading into the Oscars. While a winless night at the BAFTAs can be disheartening, historical precedents suggest that it is not an insurmountable obstacle. Films like “Everything Everywhere All at Once” (2022) and “Moonlight” (2016) have demonstrated that success at the Oscars can still be achieved despite earlier losses.

Variety Magazine

Critics have pointed out that the failure to secure any wins at the BAFTAs could dampen the film's prospects at the Oscars. The optics of tying the record for most losses may influence voters' perceptions, potentially overshadowing the film's artistic merits and Safdie's multiple nominations as director, co-producer, co-writer, and co-editor.

Variety Magazine

• “Still, the optics sting with a win-less night and a record-tying losses stat, which is not the kind of headline any campaign wants in the final stretch.” — Variety

Variety Magazine

• “Despite the BAFTA setback, “Marty Supreme” remains a formidable player in the wider awards conversation, and history offers a reminder that a rough precursor night isn’t always fatal.” — Variety

Variety Magazine

In summary, while “Marty Supreme” faced a challenging night at the BAFTAs, the film's future at the Oscars remains uncertain but hopeful, as it continues to be a strong contender in the awards circuit.

Variety Magazine