Full Breakdown
Dallas Cowboys Focus on Retaining Kicker Brandon Aubrey Ahead of Free Agency
2/24/2026, 9:54:53 PM
Key Negotiations for a Star Kicker
As the NFL offseason approaches, the Dallas Cowboys are prioritizing the retention of All-Pro kicker Brandon Aubrey, who is a restricted free agent. Cowboys executive vice president Stephen Jones confirmed that negotiations with Aubrey have been ongoing since before the 2025 season, although an agreement has yet to be reached. “It’s been a journey, but we haven’t been able to get to a point where we all agree,” Jones stated, emphasizing the team's desire to keep Aubrey.
Performance and Market Value
Brandon Aubrey has established himself as one of the top kickers in the league since joining the Cowboys in 2023. Over three seasons, he has achieved first or second-team All-Pro honors and was the NFL scoring leader in 2023. Last season, he converted 36 of 42 field goals and 47 of 48 extra-point attempts, finishing with a total of 155 points. His field goal percentage of 88.2% ranks him fifth all-time, making him a valuable asset for the Cowboys.
Spotrac estimates Aubrey's market value at approximately $26.2 million over four years, translating to an average annual salary of $6.5 million, which would make him the highest-paid kicker in the league. However, the Cowboys have the option to place a first- or second-round tender on Aubrey, which would allow them to match any offers he receives from other teams while also securing draft compensation if they choose not to match.
Strategic Options for the Cowboys
The Cowboys face a critical decision as the deadline for restricted free agents approaches on March 11. If they do not finalize a long-term deal with Aubrey by then, they will likely utilize a tender to protect their interests. A high-round tender would make it less appealing for other teams to pursue Aubrey, as they would have to forfeit a significant draft pick to the Cowboys if they signed him.
Jones indicated that the Cowboys are prepared to take necessary steps to retain Aubrey, stating, “We’ll tender him before the deadline if that’s what we have to decide.” This strategic move reflects the organization’s recognition of Aubrey's contributions and their commitment to maintaining a strong roster.
Criticism and Opposition
While the Cowboys are focused on retaining Aubrey, there are concerns regarding the potential financial implications of making him one of the highest-paid kickers. Critics argue that investing heavily in a kicker may not align with the team's broader financial strategy, especially given the need to allocate resources to other positions.
Conclusion
As the Dallas Cowboys navigate the complexities of free agency, the future of Brandon Aubrey remains a focal point. With his impressive track record and the team's strategic options, the coming weeks will be crucial in determining whether the Cowboys can secure their standout kicker for the foreseeable future.
