Controversy Surrounds Polish Documentary "Among Neighbors"

"Among Neighbors," a documentary directed by California-based filmmaker Yoav Potash, explores the murder of five Jews in the Polish town of Gniewoszów, occurring six months after the end of Nazi occupation. The film highlights the experiences of Jewish survivors returning home in 1945, only to be killed by their Polish neighbors. Premiering at the Warsaw Jewish Film Festival in November 2024, the documentary has since gained international attention and qualified for Academy Award consideration.

Times of Israel

Following its broadcast on Polish television in November 2025, "Among Neighbors" faced significant backlash from Polish officials, particularly from the office of President Karol Nawrocki, a right-wing historian known for promoting nationalist narratives regarding Poland's Holocaust history. Agnieszka Jedrzak, a minister in Nawrocki's office, criticized the film as "historical anti-Polish manipulation," asserting that it should not have been aired by a station with "Polish" in its name. This criticism aligns with the broader context of Poland's historical narrative, which has often emphasized Polish victimhood while downplaying instances of Polish complicity in the Holocaust.

Times of Israel

The Ordo Iuris Institute, a far-right Catholic think tank, filed a complaint with the National Broadcasting Council, leading to an investigation into the film. They argued that the documentary undermines Polish values and presents a false image of Poles as co-responsible for Nazi crimes. This investigation reflects ongoing tensions in Poland regarding the portrayal of its historical actions during World War II.

Times of Israel

Despite the political pushback, Telewizja Polska (TVP), the public broadcaster, has defended "Among Neighbors," asserting that it does not present an anti-Polish narrative. TVP emphasized its commitment to facilitating discussions about historical memory, stating that difficult topics can help society understand the complexities of past events. The film has also received support from the Jewish Historical Institute of Poland and the POLIN Museum of the History of Polish Jews, which have expressed their backing for the documentary's airing.

Times of Israel

"Among Neighbors" not only recounts the tragic events in Gniewoszów but also connects to a larger pattern of violence against Jews returning to Poland after liberation. A notable example is the Kielce pogrom in July 1946, where 42 Jews were killed by a mob of Polish residents, soldiers, and police. This incident significantly influenced Jewish emigration from Poland, as many survivors felt they had no future in the country.

Times of Israel

The film's exploration of the complex relationship between Poles and Jews is underscored by journalist Konstanty Gebert's metaphor of "phantom pains," suggesting that both communities continue to grapple with unresolved historical traumas. The documentary aims to confront these painful legacies, fostering dialogue about Poland's past and its implications for contemporary society.

Times of Israel

• “That just really struck me as a very different kind of story, because it was not the Germans doing the killing, it was the Poles,” — Yoav Potash, Filmmaker

Times of Israel

• “a television station that has ‘Polish’ in its name should not be broadcasting it.” — Agnieszka Jedrzak, Minister in Nawrocki’s Office

Times of Israel

• “We are open to dialogue regarding historical memory and believe that even difficult topics allow society to understand the fuller context of past events,” — TVP Statement

Times of Israel

• “Poland is still suffering from its Jewish phantom pains, and Jews are suffering from their Polish phantom pains,” — Konstanty Gebert, Journalist

Times of Israel

While the documentary has garnered support from some institutions, it has also faced significant opposition from nationalist factions within Poland. The ongoing investigation by the National Broadcasting Council raises questions about the future of the film's distribution and the broader implications for historical discourse in Poland.

Times of Israel