Full Breakdown
Matt Holliday Lists Stillwater Home for $12 Million
2/27/2026, 5:08:29 AM
Overview of the Property
Former MLB All-Star Matt Holliday has placed his luxurious home in Stillwater, Oklahoma, on the market for $12 million. The expansive 136-acre property features a range of sports-related amenities, including a professionally lit baseball field, a two-level swimming pool with a waterfall, and a private putting green. The residence boasts five bedrooms, seven bathrooms, and additional facilities such as indoor batting cages, a pickleball court, and a fully equipped home gym located in a detached four-car garage.
Holliday, who purchased the lot for $3 million in 2018, oversaw the construction of the home, which was completed in 2022. The property also includes approximately $3 million worth of custom furniture, with unique design elements such as walls wrapped in custom Gucci wallpaper.
Sentimental Value and Community Impact
Holliday has expressed that the home holds significant sentimental value, as it became his primary residence after retiring from Major League Baseball in 2018. He emphasized the importance of the home as a gathering place for friends and family, stating, "One of the things I've loved most about this home is the opportunity it has given us to gather people together." He highlighted the memorable experiences shared with college students and professional athletes, noting the home's ability to foster community and connection.
Career Highlights
Matt Holliday's professional baseball career spanned 15 seasons, primarily with the St. Louis Cardinals from 2009 to 2016, where he won the 2011 World Series. He also played for the Colorado Rockies, Oakland Athletics, and New York Yankees. Holliday was notably signed to a seven-year, $120 million contract with the Cardinals, marking the richest free-agent deal in the franchise's history. After his playing career, he transitioned into coaching, serving as an assistant coach for Oklahoma State's baseball team in 2019 and briefly as a bench coach for the Cardinals in 2022.
Official Statements & Responses
In a statement regarding the sale, Holliday reflected on the home's role in his life and the memories created there. He mentioned the warmth of the space and its ability to bring people together, emphasizing the lasting relationships formed within its walls.
Criticism & Opposition
While the property is currently the highest-priced listing in Oklahoma, some real estate analysts have raised questions about the marketability of such a high-value home, particularly in a region where luxury listings are less common. Concerns have been voiced regarding whether the unique amenities will appeal to a broad range of potential buyers.
What's Next
As the property is now listed, it remains to be seen how the market will respond to Holliday's luxurious home. The sale could set a precedent for high-end listings in the Stillwater area, potentially influencing future real estate trends in the region.
