Full Breakdown
Notre Dame's Abortion Advocate Appointment Sparks Controversy and Withdrawal
2/28/2026, 12:22:04 AM
Core Event: Ostermann Withdraws from Leadership Role
Susan Ostermann, an associate professor at the University of Notre Dame's Keough School of Global Affairs and a vocal advocate for abortion rights, has decided not to assume the role of director of the Liu Institute for Asia and Asian Studies. This decision follows significant backlash from students, faculty, and Catholic leaders, including at least 19 bishops and archbishops, who opposed her appointment due to her public stance on abortion. Ostermann's withdrawal was announced by Mary Gallagher, the dean of the Keough School, in a message to the university community.
Background & Context: The Appointment and Its Fallout
Ostermann's appointment was initially announced in January 2026, set to take effect in July. However, her history of advocating for abortion rights, including co-authoring articles that challenge anti-abortion narratives, drew immediate criticism. Notably, she argued that restrictions on abortion are harmful and counterproductive. The backlash intensified, leading to protests organized by student groups such as Notre Dame Right to Life and calls for her appointment to be rescinded.
Key Figures & Groups: Voices of Opposition
Bishop Kevin Rhoades, whose diocese includes Notre Dame, publicly condemned Ostermann's appointment, stating it was "causing scandal" among the faithful. Other bishops, including Archbishop Paul S. Coakley and Bishop Robert E. Barron, also expressed their disapproval. Student organizer Luke Woodyard emphasized the ongoing struggle for Notre Dame's Catholic identity, asserting that while Ostermann's withdrawal is a victory, the fight continues.
Official Statements & Responses
In her statement regarding her decision, Ostermann expressed that her initial acceptance of the directorship was motivated by a desire to support the institute's faculty and students. She noted that the controversy surrounding her appointment risked overshadowing the institute's work. Notre Dame's administration reiterated its commitment to the dignity of human life and acknowledged the importance of student voices in the matter.
Criticism & Opposition: Continued Concerns
Despite Ostermann's withdrawal, critics argue that her continued presence on the faculty remains incompatible with Notre Dame's Catholic mission. Kristan Hawkins, president of Students for Life of America, called for her termination, stating that allowing a professor who opposes core Catholic teachings undermines the university's identity.
What's Next: Ongoing Advocacy and Demonstrations
The controversy surrounding Ostermann's appointment has galvanized student activism at Notre Dame. The "March on the Dome," organized by various student groups, is set to continue as a demonstration of commitment to the university's Catholic values. Students and alumni alike are expected to maintain pressure on the administration to uphold these principles.
Verbatim Quotes
- “I congratulate our students for applying the vital pressure needed to get Professor Susan Ostermann to resign from her appointment,” — Luke Woodyard, Student Organizer
- “This is a big win, but the war for Notre Dame’s Catholic Identity is not yet over,” — Luke Woodyard, Student Organizer
- “ In a statement to Fox News Digital, Ostermann said, "My only goal in accepting the Liu Institute Directorship was to serve as a steward for the Institute’s world-class faculty, students and staff; it is not a position I applied for, but I was truly honored to take it on.” — Susan Ostermann, Professor
- “Notre Dame told Fox News Digital in a statement: "The University of Notre Dame remains steadfast in its unwavering commitment to the inherent dignity of the human person and to the sanctity of life at every stage.” — Notre Dame Administration
The unfolding events at Notre Dame highlight the tensions between academic freedom, institutional identity, and the deeply held beliefs of its community members.
