Full Breakdown
NFLPA Report Cards Reveal Ownership Grades and Team Dynamics
3/3/2026, 12:37:57 AM
Overview of the NFLPA Report Cards
The NFL Players Association (NFLPA) report cards, which evaluate team ownership based on player feedback, were leaked despite the NFL's efforts to keep them confidential. Conducted from November 2 to December 11, 2025, the survey involved 1,759 players rating their owners across 17 categories, including treatment of players and investment in facilities.
High Performers: A+ and A Grades
The report highlighted three ownership groups that received an A+ grade: the Denver Broncos (Walton-Penner family), Minnesota Vikings (Wilf family), and Washington Commanders (Josh Harris). The Broncos and Commanders, both under new ownership, have seen significant success on the field, with the Commanders reaching the NFC title game in 2024 and the Broncos in the AFC title game in 2025. The Vikings have consistently scored an A+ in all three years of the survey.
Teams that earned an A grade include the Atlanta Falcons (Arthur Blank), Detroit Lions (Sheila Ford Hamp), Houston Texans (Cal McNair), Indianapolis Colts (Carlie Irsay-Gordon), Jacksonville Jaguars (Shad Khan), Las Vegas Raiders (Mark Davis), Miami Dolphins (Stephen Ross), and Seattle Seahawks (Jody Allen). Notably, the Seahawks improved significantly from a C+ last year to an A this year, reflecting better player relations.
Mixed Results: B and B- Grades
Several teams received B grades, including the Dallas Cowboys (Jerry Jones), Los Angeles Rams (Stan Kroenke), New York Jets (Woody Johnson), Philadelphia Eagles (Jeff Lurie), and New York Giants (John Mara, Steve Tisch). The Jets notably improved from an F last year to a B, indicating a positive shift in player satisfaction. The New England Patriots (Robert Kraft) and Carolina Panthers (David Tepper) received B- grades, with Kraft's score improving from a D the previous year after a Super Bowl appearance.
Poor Performers: C Grades and Below
At the lower end of the spectrum, the Kansas City Chiefs (Clark Hunt) received a C+, a notable improvement from an F- two years ago, but still reflecting player dissatisfaction regarding facility investments. The Pittsburgh Steelers (Rooney family) received the second-lowest grade, with players citing poor treatment and inadequate facilities, including a failing grade for the locker room conditions. The Arizona Cardinals (Michael Bidwill) were the only team to receive an F, marking a continued trend of dissatisfaction among players.
Criticism of Ownership Practices
Critics have pointed out that the Steelers' ownership has failed to maintain player satisfaction, with reports indicating that players feel neglected regarding facility investments and overall treatment. The NFLPA survey highlighted issues such as inadequate locker room amenities and poor field conditions, which have contributed to a declining perception of the franchise.
Official Statements & Responses
The NFLPA has stated that despite the NFL's grievance to prevent public disclosure of the report cards, they will continue to collect player feedback. An NFL spokesperson criticized the survey's reliability, suggesting it lacked scientific validity and urging teams not to engage publicly with the results.
Conclusion: Implications for NFL Teams
The leaked NFLPA report cards provide a revealing look into the dynamics between players and ownership across the league. As teams prepare for the upcoming offseason, the grades may influence ownership decisions and strategies aimed at improving player relations and overall team performance. The Steelers, in particular, face mounting pressure to address player concerns and enhance their organizational reputation.
