Story perspectives

Police Scotland Under Fire for Secrecy on Asylum Crime Stats

3/5/2026

Summary

Story summary

Police Scotland faced criticism for not disclosing crime statistics linked to asylum hotels, noting figures could be influenced by protests rather than asylum seekers.
A Freedom of Information request sought details on incidents at five hotels, but the force declined to provide them.
Liam Kerr, Scottish Conservative shadow justice secretary, accused the SNP government of fostering a culture of secrecy.
Police Scotland maintained its refusal despite requests for anonymous data.

History

Historical Context

The Freedom of Information Act was enacted in the UK in 2000, promoting transparency by allowing public access to government-held information. With over 100,000 requests made annually, it has been crucial for accountability. However, Police Scotland's refusal to disclose asylum hotel crime statistics highlights ongoing challenges to transparency, which could erode public trust and exacerbate tensions surrounding asylum policies.

1 of 2

Story summary

Police Scotland faced criticism for not disclosing crime statistics linked to asylum hotels, noting figures could be influenced by protests rather than asylum seekers.
A Freedom of Information request sought details on incidents at five hotels, but the force declined to provide them.
Liam Kerr, Scottish Conservative shadow justice secretary, accused the SNP government of fostering a culture of secrecy.
Police Scotland maintained its refusal despite requests for anonymous data.

1 / 2