The Debate Over Controlled Burns in New York City Parks

In October 2025, Aaron Sexton, an assistant professor of plant science at Cornell University, proposed a controversial idea to the New York City Parks Department: the implementation of controlled burns in the city's parks. This suggestion came in the wake of a series of wildfires that had affected the region, including a notable fire in Brooklyn's Prospect Park. Sexton argued that these controlled burns, or prescribed fires, could serve to restore wildlife habitats and mitigate future wildfire risks. His research indicated that fire could be beneficial for the urban woodlands, which rarely experience such events.

New York Times

Sexton's advocacy for controlled burns is supported by his findings from studying the aftermath of the wildfires, where he observed positive ecological responses in the charred soil. However, his views are not universally accepted. Another group of researchers has conducted separate studies on the forests of New York City and reached conclusions that contradict Sexton’s findings. The Parks Department has historically refrained from using controlled burns, citing concerns over safety and public perception.

New York Times

Opponents of controlled burns raise significant concerns regarding the potential risks associated with intentionally setting fires in urban areas. They argue that the unpredictable nature of fire could lead to unintended consequences, including the possibility of uncontrolled wildfires. Additionally, there is apprehension about how such practices might affect local wildlife and the overall ecosystem.

New York Times

The New York City Parks Department has not officially endorsed the idea of controlled burns, emphasizing that the city has never implemented such practices. Officials have expressed caution regarding the implications of introducing fire into urban park management, highlighting the need for thorough risk assessments and community engagement before considering any changes to current policies.

New York Times

As climate change continues to exacerbate wildfire risks, the debate over the use of controlled burns in New York City parks is likely to intensify. Further research and discussions among scientists, city officials, and the public will be crucial in determining the future of fire management strategies in urban environments.

New York Times

“Controlled burns are a win-win strategy for today’s and tomorrow’s problems, he said.” — Aaron Sexton, Assistant Professor of Plant Science, Cornell University.

New York Times