The Rise of True Crime Podcasts: A Deep-Dive into Their Popularity and Impact

True crime podcasts have experienced significant growth in recent years, becoming a dominant genre in the podcasting landscape. As of late 2024, approximately 42 million American adults engaged with true crime podcasts monthly, with Spotify reporting a 50% increase in listening hours year-over-year in 2025. This surge reflects a broader cultural fascination with crime narratives and the intimate storytelling format that podcasts provide.

Variety Magazine

Initially a niche market, true crime podcasts faced skepticism from advertisers concerned about associating their brands with potentially grisly content. However, as the genre matured, brands recognized the strong relationships that popular creators had with their audiences. This shift has led to increased sponsorship opportunities, exemplified by Hyundai's partnership with the show “My Favorite Murder,” hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark since 2016.

Variety Magazine

Prominent figures in the true crime podcasting space include Alaina Urquhart and Ash Kelley, hosts of “Morbid,” and Vanessa Richardson, who hosts multiple shows for PAVE Studios. These creators emphasize the genre's evolution from focusing solely on the perpetrators to a more victim-centered approach, fostering empathy and community among listeners. Richardson notes that the genre has shifted to prioritize understanding victims and avoiding victimization.

Variety Magazine

The popularity of true crime podcasts reflects a societal craving for narratives that explore the darker aspects of human nature. The genre appeals particularly to women, who are nearly twice as likely as men to listen to true crime content. This demographic engagement suggests that listeners seek empowerment and community through shared discussions about crime and safety.

Variety Magazine

Industry leaders, such as Will Pearson from iHeartMedia, highlight the importance of audience connection in true crime podcasting. Pearson states, “Your audience is part of the show in a way,” emphasizing the interactive nature of the medium. Additionally, Scott Greenstein of SiriusXM notes a 68% growth in ad revenue for “Morbid” in early 2026 compared to late 2025, indicating the financial viability of the genre.

Variety Magazine

Despite its popularity, true crime podcasting faces ethical challenges, particularly regarding the portrayal of real-life tragedies. Pearson warns of the delicate nature of covering ongoing events, stressing the need for careful fact-checking and legal vetting to maintain listener trust. This scrutiny is crucial not only for legal reasons but also to uphold the integrity of the storytelling.

Variety Magazine

As the genre continues to evolve, the integration of video content into podcasts is anticipated to enhance audience engagement. Platforms like Apple Podcasts and Spotify are expanding their offerings to include video, allowing for richer storytelling experiences. Additionally, the inaugural True Crime Summit, hosted by Variety at SXSW in March 2026, aims to explore the future of the genre and its impact on media.

Variety Magazine

• “People are craving strange things,” — Alaina Urquhart, Co-host of “Morbid.”

Variety Magazine

• “It’s evolved to thinking about the victim and how to avoid becoming a victim.” — Vanessa Richardson, Host of multiple true crime shows

Variety Magazine

• “It’s really important for us to get these stories right,” — Will Pearson, President of iHeartMedia’s iHeartPodcasts division

Variety Magazine