Full Breakdown
Unearthing Philadelphia's Past: The Privy Diggers
3/7/2026, 9:38:06 PM
The Rise of Amateur Archaeology in Philadelphia
A group of approximately 15 amateur archaeologists, known as "privy diggers," is actively excavating ancient outhouses in Philadelphia, revealing artifacts from the city’s 300-year-old history. These enthusiasts, equipped with shovels, are uncovering remnants of the past, including glass bottles, pottery shards, and various household items discarded in privies. The finds can be quite valuable, with some pieces fetching hundreds or even thousands of dollars among collectors.
The interest in privy digging was sparked for Philadelphia residents Matt and Melissa Dunphy after they purchased a historic property in Old City, which included a theater with a deed dating back to 1745. During renovations, they discovered two old outhouses, leading them to excavate one immediately. Since then, they have unearthed six privies in the area and launched a podcast titled “The Boghouse” to share their findings and experiences.
The Impact of Privy Digging
The Dunphys, along with other privy diggers, are not only collecting artifacts but also delving into historical research. Each discovery prompts them to explore newspaper archives, maps, tax records, and other documents to learn about the individuals who once owned these items. Matt Dunphy expressed a philosophical view on their work, stating, “With so much waste and loss happening in the world, bringing these everyday items to the surface and putting them together for the first time in hundreds of years feels a little bit like fighting entropy.”
However, the activities of these amateur archaeologists have drawn criticism from professional archaeologists. Concerns have been raised that untrained individuals may inadvertently damage valuable historical sites. The Dunphys themselves acknowledge this tension, with Matt noting the challenges faced by professional archaeologists, who often lack the resources to protect historical sites effectively.
Criticism from the Archaeological Community
Critics argue that Philadelphia has not taken adequate measures to safeguard its buried history, especially in comparison to cities like Boston and Alexandria, Virginia. Matt Dunphy articulated this sentiment, expressing empathy for professional archaeologists who are concerned about the potential destruction of historical sites by hobbyists. He emphasized the need for increased awareness and institutional protections to preserve and document the city’s archaeological heritage.
Conclusion: A Call for Preservation
The activities of the privy diggers highlight a growing interest in Philadelphia's historical artifacts, but they also underscore the need for a balanced approach to archaeological exploration. As amateur excavators continue to unearth treasures from the past, the conversation around protecting these sites becomes increasingly important. The Dunphys hope that their efforts will contribute to a broader awareness of the significance of preserving Philadelphia's buried history.
