Full Breakdown
Long Island Man Arrested for Stashing 22 Guns Behind False Wall
3/9/2026, 2:40:18 AM
Discovery of the Arsenal
Todd Pinnell, a 54-year-old resident of Lindhurst, Long Island, was arrested on March 8, 2026, after police discovered a significant cache of firearms hidden behind a false wall in his basement closet. The Suffolk County police found a total of 22 guns, which included 14 handguns and eight assault rifles, along with ammunition feeders. Notably, four of the firearms were classified as ghost guns, which lack serial numbers and are often favored by criminals to evade detection.
Legal Proceedings and Charges
Pinnell's arrest occurred during a parole sweep of his residence, following a previous conviction for misdemeanor criminal weapons possession in 2023. He now faces 47 felony weapons charges. During a bail hearing, Judge Alonzo Jacobs remarked on the shocking nature of the discovery, setting Pinnell's bail at $100,000 cash or $200,000 bond, which was more than double the amount requested by prosecutors.
Defense and Characterization
Pinnell's attorney, Anthony Grandinette, characterized him as a gun enthusiast and a range shooter, asserting that he had no criminal record prior to his 2023 arrest. Grandinette emphasized that Pinnell has been steadily employed in the security field for a decade, with expertise in fire management. He argued that the location of the weapons posed no threat to the public, stating, “Not one of these weapons was loaded,” and suggesting that there was no intent to use the firearms.
Criticism and Opposition
While Pinnell's defense paints a picture of a responsible gun collector, the sheer number of weapons found raises concerns among law enforcement and community members. Critics argue that the presence of ghost guns and the large arsenal could indicate a potential risk, regardless of Pinnell's claims of being a collector. The case highlights ongoing debates about gun ownership, regulation, and public safety.
Official Statements
Suffolk County police have not released detailed comments regarding the implications of the discovery, but the case has drawn attention to the issue of illegal firearms and ghost guns in the community. The police's actions during the parole sweep have been defended as necessary for public safety.
What's Next
Pinnell's next court appearance is anticipated as he faces the serious charges against him. The outcome of this case may influence discussions surrounding gun laws and enforcement in New York, particularly concerning the regulation of ghost guns and the responsibilities of gun owners.
Verbatim Quotes
- “The number of weapons found could almost be said to be shocking to the conscience,” — Judge Alonzo Jacobs
- “He’s a gun enthusiast and he’s a range shooter,” — Anthony Grandinette, Attorney for Todd Pinnell
- “Not one of these weapons was loaded,” — Anthony Grandinette, Attorney for Todd Pinnell
