Ursula von der Leyen Advocates for a Realistic EU Foreign Policy Amid Middle East Conflict

Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission, has called for a significant shift in the European Union's foreign policy, emphasizing the need for a more realistic and interest-driven approach. In a recent address to EU ambassadors, she stated that Europe can no longer act as a custodian of the old-world order, which she believes is "gone and will not return." Von der Leyen argued that the EU must reassess its reliance on the rules-based international order, questioning whether it serves as a help or a hindrance to Europe's credibility as a geopolitical actor.

Ursula von der Leyen: EU foreign policy must become more realistic

This call for a new foreign policy framework comes in the wake of escalating tensions in the Middle East, particularly following US and Israeli strikes on Iran. Von der Leyen refrained from condemning these actions, instead suggesting that the Iranian regime, which she described as having "slaughtered 17,000 young people," does not warrant sympathy. She highlighted the urgent need for a credible transition in Iran, a stance that has drawn criticism from some EU officials who feel it oversteps her mandate.

EU's foreign policy chief says Iran is seeking to escalate conflict

In a demonstration of solidarity, von der Leyen and European Council President António Costa held talks with leaders from several Middle Eastern countries, including Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and Turkey. They expressed openness to enhancing maritime defensive operations aimed at protecting supply chains in the Red Sea. Von der Leyen also emphasized the importance of integrating security considerations into all EU policies and fostering partnerships with reliable global allies.

The Guardian

Von der Leyen's handling of the crisis has faced scrutiny from various diplomats and officials within the EU. Critics argue that her direct engagement with Gulf leaders and her comments suggesting regime change in Iran have overstepped her authority, creating tensions between the European Commission and member states. Some officials have expressed concern that her approach may undermine the EU's collective foreign policy stance.

Several European diplomats criticize Ursula von der Leyen for allegedly exceeding her responsibilities regarding the EU's foreign policy in managing the crisis in the Middle East.The GuardianUrsula von der Leyen: EU foreign policy must become more realisticEU's foreign policy chief says Iran is seeking to escalate conflictSouth China Morning Post

In her address, von der Leyen stated, “We will always defend and uphold the rules-based system that we helped to build with our allies, but we can no longer rely on it as the only way to defend our interests.” She also noted the need for Europe to project its power more assertively, using all available tools—economic, diplomatic, technological, and military—to counter threats.

Ursula von der Leyen: EU foreign policy must become more realistic

As the situation in the Middle East continues to evolve, von der Leyen's call for a more pragmatic and interest-driven foreign policy may lead to further discussions among EU member states about the bloc's role on the global stage. The EU's response to the ongoing conflict and its implications for European security will likely remain a focal point in upcoming diplomatic engagements.

Ursula von der Leyen: EU foreign policy must become more realistic