Nick Saban Reflects on the Missed Opportunity to Sign Drew Brees

During a recent episode of The Pivot Podcast, former Miami Dolphins head coach Nick Saban recounted the team's unsuccessful attempt to sign quarterback Drew Brees in the 2006 offseason. The Dolphins ultimately decided against acquiring Brees due to concerns over a shoulder injury he sustained in the 2005 season finale while playing for the San Diego Chargers. This decision left the Dolphins without a franchise quarterback, as Brees went on to achieve significant success with the New Orleans Saints, likely securing his place in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

Sports Illustrated

Saban revealed that Brees had passed a physical examination conducted by Dr. James Andrews, a respected surgeon who had also performed knee surgery on Daunte Culpepper, whom the Dolphins traded for instead. Despite receiving assurances from Andrews that Brees would recover well, the Dolphins' medical staff ultimately deemed him unfit to play. Saban expressed regret over the decision, noting that Brees excelled in New Orleans while Culpepper struggled, managing only four games with the Dolphins.

Sports Illustrated

In a significant revelation, Saban disclosed that he had a confidential agreement with Brees' agent regarding the failed physical. The agent requested that the Dolphins refrain from publicizing the physical's outcome, fearing it would hinder Brees' chances of signing with another team. Saban complied, withholding this information for 72 hours, during which Brees ultimately signed with the Saints.

Sports Illustrated

Saban's time with the Dolphins was brief; he coached the team for two seasons, achieving a 9-7 record in his first year and a disappointing 6-10 in his second. Following this stint, Saban transitioned to a highly successful career at the University of Alabama, where he won six national championships before retiring in 2023.

Sports Illustrated

While Saban's reflections provide insight into the decision-making process, critics may argue that the Dolphins' medical staff should have been more thorough in their evaluation of Brees. The failure to secure a quarterback of Brees' caliber has been a point of contention among Dolphins fans and analysts, who continue to question the team's judgment during that pivotal offseason.

Sports Illustrated

• “He said, ‘Oh man, Nick. You can’t tell people he didn’t pass the physical. I’ll never get him signed any place.’ I said, ‘Nobody will know, how much time do you need?’ He said, ’72 hours.’ I never told anybody. Nobody knew for 72 hours, until he signed in New Orleans.” — Nick Saban, recounting his conversation with Brees' agent

Sports Illustrated

This narrative highlights the critical decisions made during a key moment in NFL history, illustrating how a single choice can have lasting implications for a franchise.

Sports Illustrated