Story perspectives

Jeremy Carl Withdraws Amid Controversy Over Extremist Views

3/11/2026

Summary

Story summary

Jeremy Carl withdrew his nomination for assistant secretary of state for international organization affairs on March 10 after scrutiny.
The Senate confirmation hearing revealed support for great replacement theory and remarks about Jewish people.
Republican Senator John Curtis opposed Carl, saying his views were incompatible with the role.
Critics warned the nomination could harm U.S. credibility in international human rights discussions, and Carl accepted the political reality.

History

Historical Context

The Great Replacement Theory, popularized in the U.S. since Donald Trump's 2015 campaign, alleges that political elites are intentionally displacing white Americans through immigration. This conspiracy theory has gained traction among Republicans, with 61% of Trump voters endorsing it by 2022. The nomination of Jeremy Carl for assistant secretary of state in 2021 sparked debate over its implications for U.S. human rights credibility.

1 of 2

Story summary

Jeremy Carl withdrew his nomination for assistant secretary of state for international organization affairs on March 10 after scrutiny.
The Senate confirmation hearing revealed support for great replacement theory and remarks about Jewish people.
Republican Senator John Curtis opposed Carl, saying his views were incompatible with the role.
Critics warned the nomination could harm U.S. credibility in international human rights discussions, and Carl accepted the political reality.

1 / 2