Full Breakdown
Restoration of Metallica's Early Bass Tracks Sparks Debate
3/14/2026, 11:04:01 PM
Overview of the Remastering Project
A duo from TransAtlantic, known as EchoBass2 and irushforth, has undertaken a project to remaster Metallica's early catalog by restoring and amplifying the bass parts that were previously subdued in the original mixes. This initiative has reignited discussions surrounding the mixing choices made during the production of albums like *...And Justice for All*, particularly regarding Jason Newsted's contributions.
Historical Context of the Mixing Decisions
The mixing of *...And Justice for All* has long been a point of contention among fans and band members. Jason Newsted, who joined Metallica in 1986, expressed his disappointment with the final mix of the album, stating, "I was so in the dirt... I basically blocked it out." James Hetfield, the band's frontman, attributed the obscured bass sound to Newsted's tendency to double his rhythm guitar parts and the overall tonal choices made during mixing.
Key Perspectives on the Mixing Process
Mixing engineer Steve Thompson provided insight into the decisions made during the mixing process, revealing that Lars Ulrich specifically requested the bass to be significantly lowered in the mix. Thompson recounted, "He said, 'I want you to bring down the bass where you can barely audibly hear it in the mix.'" This directive was surprising to Thompson, who initially questioned Ulrich's seriousness. He clarified that the intention was not to undermine Newsted but rather to emphasize the rhythms and drums, leading to the bass's diminished presence.
Criticism of the Original Mixing Choices
Not all agree with Hetfield's explanation for the bass's obscurity. Critics argue that the mixing choices were not merely technical but also indicative of a broader disregard for Newsted's contributions. Producer Flemming Rasmussen, who worked with Metallica, noted his shock upon hearing the final mix, stating, "You forgot the bass." Irushforth, one of the remastering duo, emphasized that Newsted's basslines were more complex than merely following Hetfield's guitar parts, challenging the narrative that justified their reduction in the mix.
Implications of the Remastering Project
The remastering project aims to restore the integrity of Newsted's bass lines and challenge the long-held beliefs about the mixing decisions. Irushforth believes their work is the closest anyone has come to restoring the original basslines, which could help debunk myths surrounding Newsted's role in the band. He also pointed out that while Cliff Burton's bass was not mixed down as much, he too received a raw deal in earlier albums.
Verbatim Quotes
- “I was so disappointed when I heard the final mix. I basically blocked it out, like people do with shit.” — Jason Newsted, Former Metallica Bassist
- “He said, 'I want you to bring down the bass where you can barely audibly hear it in the mix.” — Steve Thompson, Mixing Engineer
- “When Lars came and played …And Justice for All for me, I just looked at him and said, What's that?” I said. “No, it’s not. You forgot the bass.” — Flemming Rasmussen, Producer
The remastering of Metallica's early catalog not only seeks to amplify the bass but also to revisit and reassess the historical context of the band's mixing decisions, highlighting the ongoing debate about artistic intent and production choices in music.
