Criticism of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's "No Quarter" Remarks

During a Pentagon briefing on March 13, 2023, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth made remarks stating that the U.S. would show "no quarter" to Iran amidst ongoing military operations involving the U.S. and Israel. Hegseth emphasized that the U.S. would "keep pressing, we will keep pushing, keep advancing, no quarter, no mercy." The phrase "no quarter" traditionally implies a refusal to show mercy or take prisoners, which raises significant legal and ethical concerns under international humanitarian law.

Newsweek

The International Committee of the Red Cross has noted that declaring "no quarter" is prohibited under customary international law, as codified in various legal documents including the Hague Regulations. Critics argue that such language could be interpreted as an incitement to commit war crimes, particularly if it suggests that surrendering enemies would not be spared. Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona responded to Hegseth's comments, stating that "an order to give no quarter would mean to take no prisoners and kill them instead," which he labeled as an illegal order that could endanger American service members.

Newsweek

Democratic lawmakers, including Virginia Senator Mark Warner, condemned Hegseth's rhetoric, asserting that it undermines the Geneva Conventions and the principles of international law. Warner characterized Hegseth's comments as "unacceptable" and potentially harmful to U.S. military personnel. Brian Finucane, a senior adviser at the International Crisis Group, expressed concern that such "belligerent, lawless rhetoric" could influence military conduct on the battlefield.

Newsweek

Marko Milanovic, an international law professor at the University of Reading, suggested that Hegseth's comments might not be intended as a call for war crimes but rather as an example of the exaggerated rhetoric often associated with former President Donald Trump and his advisers. Milanovic noted that the context of Hegseth's statement could be interpreted as political hyperbole rather than a literal directive to disregard the laws of war.

Newsweek

In addition to his controversial remarks, Hegseth also commented on the condition of Iran's new supreme leader, Mojtaba Khamenei, claiming he had been wounded and was likely disfigured. Hegseth's assertions regarding Khamenei's health were made without providing evidence, and Iran has not confirmed any details about the leader's condition.

Newsweek

Hegseth's statements have sparked significant debate regarding the implications of military rhetoric and its adherence to international law. As the U.S. continues its military operations, the potential consequences of such language on both legal and operational fronts remain a critical concern for lawmakers and military experts alike.

Newsweek